EDD 9952 Week 8 Assignment Literature Review
Literature Review
Learner and Specialization Information (to be completed by learner)
Learner Name | |
Learner Email | |
Learner ID Number | |
Instructor Name | |
Specialization | |
Program Director Name | |
Program Director Email | |
Name of Project Site | |
Name of Person Giving Authorization to use Site. | |
Type of Organization | |
Learner Role at Site | |
APPROVED BY INSTRUCTOR Name & Date |
Instructions
Use the headings below to complete the literature review. For information and examples specific to each heading, refer to the Literature Review Guide.
Introduction and Overview of the Literature Review
If students are not doing well in mathematics in middle school, it is a crisis that will impact performance over the long term, as well as institutional responsibilities. This identified school has very poor mathematics performance, with only 1/3 of students on track in maths in the last few years compared to district and state expectations.
Therefore, the review examines empirical evidence regarding professional learning, instructional coaching, using data to inform practice, and collaborative learning as strategic interventions to support the teaching of mathematics for students with diverse learning needs in middle schools to narrow the gaps in student mathematics achievement.
The purpose of the applied improvement project (AIP) is to implement a systematic, evidence-based intervention in mathematics that occurs in the middle school setting, involving instructional coaching, differentiated instructional planning, and collaborative data examination. The plan will be based on teacher capacity building, enhancing the quality of teaching and raising the percentage of students scoring more than 32-45 in one year.
Incorporating instructional coaching, differentiated lesson design, and collaborative data analysis, when done together, can measure and enhance teacher effectiveness and mathematics achievement with students, particularly when the interventions are sustained and data-driven (Bellacicco et al., 2025; Ventista & Brown, 2023). The Applied Improvement Project literature review is intended to be the academic foundation that will link the Applied Improvement Project to the literature that underlies the chosen intervention model. Examples of how evidence-based instruction can be aligned to the institutional goals of sustained improvement to advance instruction and improve equity of mathematics achievement by different student subgroups are provided.
Figure 1
Applied Improvement Project Model

Note. This figure shows the three major phases of the applied improvement project model and how the 10 steps of this model were completed within the advanced doctoral courses. The shaded sections resemble the three major phases, the circular icons resemble the 10 steps, and the line between the icons resembles the connection between each step within the appropriate phase. Retrieved from https://media.capella.edu/CourseMedia/edd8522element20223/wrapper.asp. Not in the public domain.
Problem of Practice and Background
The school is in a critical academic situation because of mathematics outcomes that have been poor. Specific instructional improvement is needed in the area of mathematics. The organizing problem is that students at the identified level have lower-than-district and state expectations for performance in middle school mathematics (32% state-proficient performance, based on the District Math Benchmark Report Fall 2024). A variety of systemic problems are affecting the implementation of instruction and learning, such as limited teacher content knowledge, teacher confidence in math pedagogy, and inconsistent application. The barriers are consistent with the national trends where teacher professional learning and supports using data are scarce in high-poverty and diverse schools.
Reduced participation and limited alignment to classroom practice were detected in past remediation efforts, such as optional tutoring and standardized test preparation (Plooy et al., 2024; Ruhter & Karvonen, 2023), leading to gaps in the foundational skills (e.g., fractions, algebraic reasoning, and multistep problem solving).
For instance, Lee and Vongkulluksn (2022) found that teachers who had less frequent content-specific professional development had lower levels of instructional coherence and lower mathematics growth for students. Similarly, O’Connor and Park (2023) emphasized the value of professional communities of collaboration because that would enable teachers to feel more effective in using shared instruction and data to reflect on the impact of their teaching. The instructional need noticed at this school is matched at the national level, as fewer than 40% of eighth-grade students are proficient in mathematics.
Hence, it is extremely important to have intervention that works on collaborative, structured, and sustained teacher professional learning to minimize the effect of poverty, lack of teachers, and poor attendance on the increasing achievement gap in the school (Cojorn & Sonsupap, 2024). Research-based strategies that directly impact teachers’ capacities, collaborative practice, and data-informed decisions are essential to this research, given the interconnected instructional and contextual issues. Hence, it is important to conduct a literature analysis to find models and approaches that have proven effective in improving mathematics learning in schools that have similar conditions. The review will provide a theoretical and empirical basis that will help make thoughtful selection of the improvement intervention and purposeful implementation.
Purpose and Organization of the Literature Review
The purpose of the Applied Improvement Project is to improve mathematics achievement for students by building teachers’ instructional capacity by supporting teacher job-embedded professional development, instructional coaching, and collaborative data analysis. The literature review will be designed in a way that will allow the literature to form the basis of a coherent argument for this intervention. The theoretical foundation section provides an overview of theories and models for adult learning, professional growth, and organizational change that account for teacher development in new teaching skills.
The problem of practice section reviews the literature on the topic of persistent mathematics underachievement in high-needs school contexts and identifies structural and instructional barriers relevant to the context identified. Finally, research design and evaluation tools for systematic implementation and monitoring of activities for instructional improvement are provided in the methodological considerations section. The four sections build a solid scholarly base for selecting, designing, and piloting the planned intervention.
Library Search Process
The literature search process involved a thorough search of peer-reviewed scholarly journals and works from the past 5 years using various databases in the Capella University Library, such as ERIC (Education Resources Information Center), ProQuest Education Database, Education Source, and SAGE Journals. To find recent (2010-2025) open-access publications in mathematics instruction, professional development, and data-driven school improvement, supplementary searches were conducted in Google Scholar and ResearchGate. The following combination of search terms was used: mathematics achievement and teacher professional development, instructional collaboration and data-driven instruction, middle school and student performance gaps.
The databases identified were selected because they are academic, peer-reviewed, and have wide coverage of educational research with quality and evidence-based research that matched the research focus. A total of 143 articles were found in the search. After screening the titles, abstracts, and relevance to the problem of practice, 57 articles were selected for full review, and 25 articles were determined to be reflective of the intervention focus and empirical rigor. Existing research work or studies of adult learning that predated this period were included if there was evidence that they were seminal in the theories of work and/or adult learning.
The search included Boolean operators and inclusion criteria, with the intent to focus on studies involving middle school education, teacher capacity building, and mathematics instructional outcomes that were empirical, systematic reviews, or meta-analyses. The following search terms were systematically used for a comprehensive search of the literature: “mathematics achievement AND middle school students,” “teacher professional development AND instructional coaching,” “data-driven decision making in education,” “differentiated instruction AND student performance,” “equity in mathematics education,” “job-embedded learning AND teacher efficacy,” and “school improvement interventions AND student outcomes. The terms were chosen to represent a broad spectrum of mathematics education research that is relevant to student achievement, teacher practice, and mathematics education interventions, in order to explore the factors that impact instructional effectiveness and student outcomes related to mathematics education.
Theoretical Foundation for the Applied Improvement Project
The Applied Improvement Project (AIP) utilizes the Social Cognitive Theory (SCT) of Albert Bandura that emphasizes the interaction among beliefs, behaviors, and environment as key factors in the learning and performance process. This project is relevant to SCT because it has a connection with bringing about change in teacher practice and in student outcomes. The concepts of the theory (job-embedded professional learning, instructional coaching, and collaborative data review) are consistent with the idea of social learning, modeling, and self-efficacy as essential elements of sustaining instructional change, all of which are integral to the AIP.
Social Learning and Observational Modeling
According to SCT, people learn from others around them in their social world. Learning occurs through observing, guided practice, and feedback for skill reinforcement in the context of education. Hosseini et al. (2025) and Yuan et al. (2024) argued that teachers’ structured observations and reflective conversations are crucial because they create coherence and confidence in teaching. Coaching cycles and group conversations about data provide a scaffolded approach for teachers to learn by modelling, practice, and feedback to support continuous professional learning and collective improvement within this AIP.
Self-Efficacy and Professional Confidence
Self-efficacy is one of the main constructs in SCT, defined as a person’s belief in his or her ability to plan and execute behaviors that lead to desired outcomes. Self-efficacy is another factor that is related to persistence, adaptability, and effectiveness in the teaching context. Based on the study results, Li (2023) stated that teachers’ self-efficacy has a positive correlation with the use of innovative methods and the ability to keep students engaged in learning. Similarly, Gordon et al. (2022) found a mastery experience and verbal reinforcement to be factors that led teachers to feel confident in the difficult pedagogies. The AIP will include job-embedded professional development and feedback loops to strengthen teachers’ confidence in their own ability to teach mathematics while helping to improve student success in mathematics.
Reciprocal Determinism in Instructional Change
In Bandura’s theory of reciprocal determinism, the environment, cognition, and behavior continually affect each other. This is how teacher beliefs, what teachers do in the classroom, and the school culture work together in a dynamic way in a school improvement process. Johnson et al. (2024) and Khan et al. (2024) emphasized the need for teaching to take place within collaborative professional environments to enhance teacher effectiveness and quality teaching. The mechanisms in this AIP are based on reciprocal determinism, which brings together data reviews and coaching sessions as building blocks to link individual growth with improvement and shared accountability.
Application of SCT to Professional Learning Design
The current uses of SCT highlight the versatility of SCT in the current context of education, including the use of technology for professional development and the use of student data to drive professional development. Professional learning through SCT can result in observable improvements in teacher performance when combined with observation, feedback, and collaboration, as illustrated by Li et al. (2025).
Furthermore, a study of SCT-informed professional learning revealed that the likelihood of instructional change being sustained is highest when teachers continue to have successful experiences using the new practices in authentic contexts and when coaches give teachers timely feedback (Gordon et al., 2022; Johnson, 2024). The results directly influenced the design of the AIP, and coaching and collaborative data review were selected as part of the intervention, as opposed to as separate workshops or training sessions. The project will seek increased fidelity of implementation, as the project will encourage alignment of intervention activities with interventions known to increase self-efficacy and collective professional identity and increase the likelihood of improved mathematics instruction in classrooms.
Differences and Ongoing Debates in Applying Social Cognitive Theory
Professional learning based on the SCT is common, and there is some conflict over the extent to which observations and SCT translate into ongoing professional learning in practice. Although higher teachers’ self-efficacy is believed to lead to improved student outcomes, there are concerns that contextual factors such as limited planning time, inconsistent coaching support, and unclear curriculum expectations can reduce opportunities to implement new practices and limit the impact of teachers’ self-efficacy on student outcomes (Hosseini et al., 2025; Li, 2023; Yang & Du, 2024).
Some other studies also indicate that there are differences in teachers’ internalisation and understanding of the demonstrated practices, years of experience, teaching background, and willingness to try peer monitoring (Yuan et al., 2024). These conversations are indicative of the need for consistent, focused cycles of coaching in the identified school, where teachers’ readiness and confidence with regard to mathematics instruction is well distributed, and for regular mathematics routines and explicit expectations of the use of instructional strategies.
Review of the Literature Related to the Problem of Practice
Common teaching and environmental issues are highlighted that are similar to those observed in the selected school with underperformance in middle school mathematics. Some of the factors that affect student learning highlighted in the District Math Benchmark Report (Fall 2024) include: teacher preparation content knowledge, teacher pedagogical confidence, clunky implementation of differentiated instruction, and infrequent use of formative data by teachers, along with student-level factors like poverty and chronic absenteeism.
The combination of the need for instruction and the need for organisation, combined with the community and student needs, is shown to be a challenge for students’ development of fundamental mathematical skills, such as multistep problem solving, algebraic reasoning, and fractions (Amalina & Vidákovich, 2023). The research literature indicates that targeted, job-based professional development and structured data protocols are important strategies to support teachers’ instructional improvement and close the achievement gap, particularly when the student population is more than 70% economically disadvantaged and the current school’s average proficiency rate is 32% (Kelty & Wakabayashi, 2020; National Center for Education Statistics, 2023).
Theme 1: Job-embedded, content-focused professional development & instructional coaching
The body of recent research is also expanding and highlights the role of job-embedded, content-driven professional development and instructional coaching for persistent instructional gaps and teacher capacity in mathematics education. A synthesis of multiple studies by Gordon et al. (2022) resulted in the finding that professional development, such as mastery experiences, vicarious learning, and coaching cycles, has an impact on teacher self-efficacy and teacher instructional change. Li (2023) explored teacher self-efficacy, resilience, and burnout and found that PD interventions could have a positive effect on teacher well-being if they increase teacher efficacy, reduce teacher burnout, and boost teacher work engagement, indicating a well-being pathway for the effects of PD on teacher instruction.
Coaching and professional development, however, were not effective with teachers who worked with students with extensive support needs unless they also received supports and structures for using data with students, according to Ruhter and Karvonen (2023). In addition, Li et al. (2025) expanded the body of evidence to technology-mediated PD, and their elements—mastery, modeling, and verbal persuasion—were transformed into digital coaching and cycles of practice, which further highlighted the importance of continued content-specific and practice opportunities. The research results provide clear evidence of how sustained coaching cycles, structured observation and feedback (S.O.F.), and continued content-specific coaching will be a key component of the planned intervention at the chosen school.
Theme 2: Collaborative data use, differentiated instruction, and contextual barriers (poverty, attendance)
Existing studies support the importance of data use collaboratives and differentiated instruction as both interventions that influence mathematics achievement. The research below also illustrates the relationship between contextual issues (such as poverty and chronic absenteeism) and the effectiveness of under-resourced school contexts. Visscher (2020) examined several intervention studies and found that the use of data to inform decision-making is supported by schools that can gather and analyze formative data, as well as when data is used collaboratively; Khan et al. (2024) concluded that teachers’ confidence in using data (data-use self-efficacy) was significantly related to teacher frequency and quality of instructional adjustments when using data collaboratively.
In their study on teachers’ practices in mathematics reasoning, Mukuka et al. (2023) identified that teachers’ limited collaborative preparation time and lack of differentiated instruction hindered their ability to address the gaps in reasoning skills of the various learners. By contrast, personalized/adaptive learning technologies had an impact on engagement and performance if the technologies were tightly integrated into classroom routines and supported by teacher oversight, as noted by Plooy et al. (2024), suggesting that personalized/adaptive learning technologies have the potential to help, but with teacher capacity and collaborative planning.
By comparison, Kelty and Wakabayashi (2020) reviewed the significance of family and community involvement and the importance of contextual factors like poverty, lack of parental engagement at school, and food insecurity, which can significantly affect attendance and out-of-school learning time and can get in the way of classroom interventions if school–community strategies are not put in place. The literature reviewed above shows that collaborative data use and differentiation are successful levers for enhancing math outcomes. Therefore, the collaborative data team structures and the differentiated planning supports that will be provided at the selected site will enable teachers to have the instructional capacity and shared routines needed to use data to inform instructional adjustments, particularly in a high poverty/high absenteeism school.
Critique and Synthesis
The central theme of teacher capacity and collaborative data use to enhance mathematics results for middle grades is well supported by numerous problem of practice studies. Rather, the factors that are consistently and repeatedly identified across studies as being associated with improving instructional change are teacher self-efficacy as a mediator of instructional change and confidence in data use as a predictor of adaptive instruction (Gordon et al., 2022; Johnson et al., 2024; Khan et al., 2024). However, there are a few cons and concerns about it. Many efficacy studies are carried out in districts that have more resources or are better resourced, or in urban districts where PD structures are already in place, and as a result, are not generalizable to the selected school, which has the characteristics of a rural and high-poverty school.
Another challenge is that promising interventions are often multi-component, which makes it difficult to separate out which parts of the intervention are responsible for the success and how the intervention can be scaled effectively without a significant increase in costs (Visscher, 2020; Plooy et al., 2024). Third, poverty and attendance are often not analyzed as variables to attend to directly, but as background variables; Kelty and Wakabayashi (2020); Mukuka et al. (2023) point out that interventions that impact teaching in the school have not been widely implemented without family-engagement and attendance strategies.
Finally, there is a methodological gap: there are fewer longitudinal, randomized, or quasi-experimental studies that examine fidelity across multiple years in contexts where there are scarce resources, and fewer studies that measure fidelity in addition to changes in student learning at scale (Plooy et al. 2024). Combining these positions is indicative of a new ‘theory’ for the improvement project identified and applied in the school. There is a high likelihood that for any kind of enduring student success, the intervention must be multi-layered, that is it must include j, content-specific coaching, plus planned collaborative data teams, as well as differentiated community or attendance strategies. Implementation fidelity and cost or resource needs will be documented in the model to facilitate the effectiveness and scalability of the model in a high-poverty, rural middle school setting.
Review of the Literature Related to the Intervention or Solution
Theme 1: Job-Embedded Professional Development and Instructional Coaching
Teacher professional development and instructional coaching are emerging as essential strategies to enhance the effectiveness of teachers and students, especially in schools that are struggling and high-poverty. Gore and Rosser (2020) found that teachers who engaged in professional learning focused on content and sustained over time were more likely to show measurable gains in student achievement in mathematics and to have increased instructional coherence. Likewise, Glover et al. (2023) found that professional learning that is integrated into teachers’ daily routines and accompanied by instructional coaching leads to teachers implementing strategies more routinely and adjusting instruction to meet students’ needs. Conversely, Ventista and Brown (2023) pointed out that professional learning sessions that were not integrated into the classroom or followed up with further PD were not effective in improving teaching and learning. The results overall highlighted the need for ongoing, context-specific professional learning opportunities that are directly linked to classroom practices.
Instructional coaching is a critical link between theory and practice. Coaches offer tailored feedback, model teaching strategies, and create reflective conversation to increase pedagogical learning. Research in high poverty school settings also indicates that coaching can reduce teacher isolation and contribute to adaptive pedagogy in conjunction with peer collaboration and consistent feedback cycles (Reddy et al., 2021). Similarly, Raley et al. (2022) reported that teachers who participated in structured cycles of coaching showed substantial gains in instructional fidelity and students’ engagement, especially when coaching was connected to schoolwide data purposes and was supported by leadership. The evidence together suggests that job-based professional learning combined with instructional coaching leads to instructional coherence, increased teacher confidence, and tangible student achievement. Such a strategy is in keeping with the AIP’s vision of high-quality teacher professional development in mathematics for middle school students.
One of the most promising models in the job-embedded learning research is the coaching cycle that consists of four phases: observation, feedback, co-planning, and instructional modeling. Raley et al. (2022) and Glover et al. (2023) noted that this structured feedback loop is a scalable and adaptable approach that enhances instruction and promotes teacher reflection. The current intervention will take the form of a coaching cycle with weekly collaborative planning sessions and coaching conversations through walkthroughs. There is evidence to support the selection of this model because it shows that coherence, teacher confidence, and student engagement can be enhanced when feedback is integrated into the learning process. The intervention will be based on job-embedded coaching cycles to facilitate school-wide instructional improvement and boost teacher capacity in middle school mathematics, and align with research that emphasizes the need for ongoing, context-specific professional learning.
Theme 2: Collaborative Data-Driven Instruction and Differentiation
Structured collaboration around data and differentiated instruction are essential components of effective school improvement. Visscher (2020) found that teachers participating in collective data interpretation greatly increased the effectiveness of data-based decision-making in instructional targeting. Likewise, Pozas et al. (2022) revealed that teachers who had greater confidence in data use had a greater impact on student performance and more effective differentiation. In contrast, Ruhter and Karvonen (2023) found that schools that lacked data-review protocols tended to leave instructional differences to chance, or to prepare students for standardized tests, leading to a disjointed approach to making instructionally sound decisions and student growth. These comparisons show that collaborative and structured data conversations help teachers pinpoint learning gaps early and adjust instruction earlier to better meet the needs of students.
Collaborative data use also fosters shared accountability and builds collective teacher efficacy. Plooy et al. (2024) emphasized that integrating data review cycles into professional learning communities encourages teachers to view data as a tool for improvement rather than evaluation. Such environments support trust, reflection, and continuous instructional refinement. Similarly, Khan et al. (2024) found that teachers with higher data-use self-efficacy were more likely to implement adaptive instructional strategies that directly improved student performance, especially when supported through structured collaboration. When combined with differentiation practices, data collaboration ensures equitable access to learning opportunities across diverse student populations.
The findings affirm the need for structured data-use protocols within professional learning frameworks to promote sustained instructional improvement, an approach central to the AIP’s intervention design. Among collaborative data practices, the data team cycle stands out as a replicable and scalable model in similar school contexts. Plooy et al. (2024) described how structured meetings that follow a consistent protocol, reviewing student work, identifying misconceptions, planning differentiation, and monitoring outcomes, promote shared responsibility and continuous instructional refinement.
The intervention will incorporate biweekly data-team meetings using a common data protocol aligned to benchmark and formative assessments (Al-Dokhny et al., 2021). Such adaptation is justified by evidence linking structured collaboration to increased instructional precision and collective teacher efficacy. By embedding structured data cycles into collaborative planning routines, the intervention aims to improve instructional decision-making and ensure equitable learning support across student groups.
Critique and Synthesis
The research examined demonstrates a clear trend in the literature: the most effective models of teacher learning and instructional quality are continuous, collaborative, and context-specific PD models. Both the research of Gore and Rosser (2020) and Glover et al. (2023) confirmed a connection between ongoing, job-based professional learning directly related to classroom practice and improved instructional coherence and student achievement. They also reinforced this argument by showing, as did Reddy et al. (2021) and Raley et al. (2022), that instructional coaching offers a necessary feedback loop to connect theory and practice together.
Ventista and Brown (2023), however, warned that teacher PD that is not followed up with coaching does not ensure teacher growth over time, and pointed to the need for embedded, iterative PD structures. Comparing studies that focus on the use of data to guide instruction, similar patterns emerge. Visscher (2020) and Pozas et al. (2022) showed how collective data interpretation enhances teachers’ capacity to deliver differentiated instruction and to effectively track student progress.
These findings were echoed by Plooy et al. (2024) and Khan et al. (2024), who found that collaborative data teams were a source of collective efficacy and professional trust, and thus a driver for continued instructional improvement. In contrast, Ruhter and Karvonen (2023) reported that data use can be disparate and inequitable with no systematic support and procedures. The results together highlight that professional development and/or data tools alone are not enough to produce meaningful instructional improvements, but it is crucial that coaching, collaboration, and well-designed support structures are embedded in a sustained way to make teacher learning sticky and lead to regular high-quality classroom instruction.
While there is consensus about the importance of coaching and data sharing, there are some methodological and contextual challenges. Glover et al. (2023) and Pozas et al. (2022) conducted studies in well-resourced or urban environments that may not be able to be generalized to rural or high-poverty environments like the identified school. Additionally, most research focuses on short-term gains and not sustainability – or fidelity of implementation – with no answers on durability or cost-effectiveness (Ventista & Brown, 2023; Raley et al., 2022). Although the evidence base as a whole backs up integrated models of professional development, very few studies can isolate exactly where the effects of coaching, data collaboration, or differentiation are leading to the greatest effect sizes.
The reviewed literature provides compelling theoretical and empirical support for a unified intervention model of job-embedded professional development, instructional coaching, and collaborative data use. The three elements support each other: coaching strengthens the application of skills, data deepens reflection, and differentiated instruction guarantees equity in outcomes. Fidelity monitoring, structured leadership support, and community engagement will be critical to sustainability and scalability for implementation in a resource-constrained, high-poverty middle school environment (Ventista & Brown, 2023; Raley et al., 2022).
The AIP design is based on these findings, incorporating the most consistently effective features of the design and correcting for the limitations found in the ability to adapt the design and assess its effectiveness at the context level and over time. The intervention will be based upon the collective results and incorporate three strands that will be mutually reinforcing: (a) job-embedded PD, (b) structured instructional coaching cycles, and (c) collaborative data team protocols for differentiation. They each focus on an essential lever identified in the literature – teacher instructional capacity, support for regular implementation of best practices, and a responsiveness to student needs that is data-driven. The identified strategies are integrated into one overall schoolwide improvement framework, thereby enabling the intervention to promote enduring improvements in 8th grade mathematics proficiency.
The research examined demonstrates a clear trend in the literature: the most effective models of teacher learning and instructional quality are continuous, collaborative, and context-specific PD models. Both the research of Gore and Rosser (2020) and Glover et al. (2023) confirmed a connection between ongoing, job-based professional learning directly related to classroom practice and improved instructional coherence and student achievement. They also reinforced this argument by showing, as did Reddy et al. (2021) and Raley et al. (2022), that instructional coaching offers a necessary feedback loop to connect theory and practice together. Ventista and Brown (2023), however, warned that teacher PD that is not followed up with coaching does not ensure teacher growth over time, and pointed to the need for embedded, iterative PD structures.
Comparing studies that focus on the use of data to guide instruction, similar patterns emerge. Visscher (2020) and Pozas et al. (2022) showed how collective data interpretation enhances teachers’ capacity to deliver differentiated instruction and to effectively track student progress. These findings were echoed by Plooy et al. (2024) and Khan et al. (2024), who found that collaborative data teams were a source of collective efficacy and professional trust, and thus a driver for continued instructional improvement. In contrast, Ruhter and Karvonen (2023) reported that data use can be disparate and inequitable with no systematic support and procedures. The results together highlight that professional development and/or data tools alone are not enough to produce meaningful instructional improvements, but it is crucial that coaching, collaboration, and well-designed support structures are embedded in a sustained way to make teacher learning sticky and lead to regular high-quality classroom instruction.
While there is consensus about the importance of coaching and data sharing, there are some methodological and contextual challenges. Glover et al. (2023) and Pozas et al. (2022) conducted studies in well-resourced or urban environments that may not be able to be generalized to rural or high-poverty environments like the identified school. Additionally, most research focuses on short-term gains and not sustainability – or fidelity of implementation – with no answers on durability or cost-effectiveness (Ventista & Brown, 2023; Raley et al., 2022). Although the evidence base as a whole backs up integrated models of professional development, very few studies can isolate exactly where the effects of coaching, data collaboration, or differentiation are leading to the greatest effect sizes.
The reviewed literature provides compelling theoretical and empirical support for a unified intervention model of job-embedded professional development, instructional coaching, and collaborative data use. The three elements support each other: coaching strengthens the application of skills, data deepens reflection, and differentiated instruction guarantees equity in outcomes. Fidelity monitoring, structured leadership support, and community engagement will be critical to sustainability and scalability for implementation in a resource-constrained, high-poverty middle school environment (Ventista & Brown, 2023; Raley et al., 2022).
The AIP design is based on these findings, incorporating the most consistently effective features of the design and correcting for the limitations found in the ability to adapt the design and assess its effectiveness at the context level and over time. The intervention will be based upon the collective results and incorporate three strands that will be mutually reinforcing: (a) job-embedded PD, (b) structured instructional coaching cycles, and (c) collaborative data team protocols for differentiation. They each focus on an essential lever identified in the literature – teacher instructional capacity, support for regular implementation of best practices, and a responsiveness to student needs that is data-driven. The identified strategies are integrated into one overall schoolwide improvement framework, thereby enabling the intervention to promote enduring improvements in 8th grade mathematics proficiency.
Review of the Literature Related to the Methods
This review article suggests various methodological frameworks that can be applied in organizing the undertaken improvement project. An ongoing, iterative, and practice-integrated approach to professional learning emerged as a common method in the research. For instance, Glover et al. (2023) and Raley et al. (2022) conducted coaching and collaboration in iterative cycles involving observation, feedback, and instructional adjustment. This was an incremental model that allowed incremental improvements by teachers—and continuous support was provided—and discontinuous changes in professional learning and implementation were less effective. This process of improvement – coaching, rehearsal, feedback, reflection, adjustment – is the same in AIP since it is directly linked to an observable and progressive shift in teaching practices.
The identified method is suitable for the purpose of the project – to develop mathematical confidence and skills over time in a structured way for the teachers. In addition, collaborative approaches were used for data review, where teachers supported each other in analysing children’s work, discussing how to respond to children’s work, and monitoring the impact of adaptations made to the lesson, as described by Visscher (2020) and Plooy et al. (2024). The identified processes were more about the collective processes of sensemaking than individual interpretations, which increased the sense of collective responsibility and teacher efficacy.
The same reasons will be used to integrate biweekly collaborative data team meetings into AIP: Making more sense with data, aligning learning expectations will be aligned, and continuing improvement. Reddy et al. (2021) and Pozas et al. (2022) both highlighted the importance of tailoring the methodology to the local school context and the teacher’s needs, as well as the importance of not implementing coaching and data collaboration in a generic manner. The schools that were not utilizing structured supports or continuity were not consistently implementing them, requiring clear routines and implementation with support of the leadership (Ruhter & Karvonen, 2023). In AIP, the implementation plan will be adapted to the site, supported by leadership, and monitored for fidelity, and the plan will make sure the intervention is responsive, implementable, and sustainable in a high-poverty middle school setting.
Literature Review Summary
The literature reviewed provides a solid conceptual and empirical base for the Applied Improvement Project (AIP) that focuses on enhancing mathematics achievement of middle school students. Research clearly demonstrates that the ability of the teacher, continuous instructional support, and planned teacher collaboration are key factors in improving student achievement. Gore and Rosser (2020) and Glover et al. (2023) emphasized the need for job-embedded, daily instructional-bounded professional development in order to make impactful changes. Similarly, Reddy et al. (2021) and Raley et al. (2022) showed instructional coaching helps to connect the learning of new instructional strategies with their consistent use in the classroom.
Findings were supportive of central aspects of the AIP: professional learning and ongoing instructional coaching to support teacher confidence and instructional cohesion. Group and focused instruction are also part of using data to guide instruction. The interpretation of data and the use of the outcomes of formative assessments that are concluded by teachers in a collective way lead to better learning outcomes for students when teachers use them to differentiate instruction (Visscher, 2020; Pozas et al., 2022). Similarly, Plooy et al. (2024) and Khan et al. (2024) reported that shared routines of data use help to build a sense of shared teacher effectiveness and shared responsibility. But Ruhter and Karvonen (2023) highlighted the potential for inconsistency and a lack of connection between data use and instruction without clear data protocols and follow-through structures.
Literature of this type reinforces the additional significance of having formal, regular data review processes, which AIP provides through frequent data team meetings to collaborate. Although the research basis for the advantages of job-embedded learning and the use of collaboration with data is very compelling, there are still some gaps in the literature. The studies most relevant and similar to the present one are conducted in well resourced, urban schools, which do not provide direction for use in high-poverty schools in rural areas such as the selected school.
Additionally, research was identified as being mostly in the short-term rather than long-term sustainability (Ventista & Brown, 2023; Raley et al., 2022). The gaps underscore the need for the AIP’s focus on the critical roles of local adaptation, ongoing fidelity monitoring and ongoing implementation. The articles as a whole indicate that improving middle school math outcomes requires more than just isolated training or remediation, and requires a system of teacher support that includes job-embedded PD, structured coaching, and data-driven, collaborative planning. The AIP directly addressed the findings through implementation of an integrated model of professional learning that reinforces instructional practice and boosts mathematics proficiency. The AIP expands the research literature that has previously been grounded in the evidence base by investigating feasibility, sustainability, and instructional impact in a context in which these are not examined, and where the higher poverty levels and rural environment would likely impede existing research findings.
References
Al-Dokhny, A., Drwish, A., Alyoussef, I., & Al-Abdullatif, A. (2021). Students’ intentions to use distance education platforms: An investigation into expanding the technology acceptance model through social cognitive theory. Electronics, 10(23), e2992. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics10232992
Amalina, I. K., & Vidákovich, T. (2023). Cognitive and socioeconomic factors that influence the mathematical problem-solving skills of students. Heliyon, 9(9), e19539. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e19539
Bellacicco, R., Capone, F., Sorrentino, C., & Di Martino, V. (2025). The role of active breaks and curriculum-based active breaks in enhancing executive functions and math performance, and in reducing math anxiety in primary school children: A systematic review. Education Sciences, 15(1), 47. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci15010047
Christensen, A. A., & Jerrim, J. (2025). Professional learning communities and teacher outcomes. A cross-national analysis. Teaching and Teacher Education, 156, 104920. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2024.104920
Cojorn, K., & Sonsupap, K. (2024). A collaborative professional development and its impact on teachers’ ability to foster higher-order thinking. Journal of Education and Learning (Edisi Elektronik)/Journal of Education and Learning, 18(2), 561–569. https://doi.org/10.11591/edulearn.v18i2.21182
Eryilmaz, N., Kennedy, A. I., Strietholt, R., & Johansson, S. (2025). Teacher job satisfaction: International evidence on the role of school working conditions and teacher characteristics. Studies in Educational Evaluation, 86(4), e101474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2025.101474
Glover, T. A., Reddy, L. A., & Crouse, K. (2023). Instructional coaching actions that predict teacher classroom practices and student achievement. Journal of School Psychology, 96, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2022.10.006
Gordon, D., Blundell, C., Mills, R., & Bourke, T. (2022). Teacher self-efficacy and reform: A systematic literature review. The Australian Educational Researcher, 50, 801–821. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13384-022-00526-3
Gore, J., & Rosser, B. (2020). Beyond content-focused professional development: Powerful professional learning through genuine learning communities across grades and subjects. Professional Development in Education, 48(2), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2020.1725904
Harris, S. (2025, January 29). The nation’s report card shows declines in reading, some progress in 4th grade math. Nagb.gov. https://www.nagb.gov/news-and-events/news-releases/2025/nations-report-card-decline-in-reading-progress-in-math.html
Hosseini, Z., Tavafian, S., Ahmadi, O., & Maghbouli, R. (2025). Assessing the impact of a social cognitive theory-based educational intervention on ergonomic behaviors: a randomized controlled trial utilizing a learning-by-doing approach. BioMed Central Public Health, 25(1), e3304. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-025-24533-y
Johnson, H. N., Lo, Y., & Nichols, M. E. (2024). Data-driven coaching model to support teachers’ implementation of opportunities to respond. Educational Research and Development Journal, 27(2), 1–26. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1462677
Kelty, N. E., & Wakabayashi, T. (2020). Family engagement in schools: Parent, educator, and community perspectives. SAGE Open, 10(4), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244020973024
Khan, N. A., Maialeh, R., Akhtar, M., & Ramzan, M. (2024). The role of AI self-efficacy in religious contexts in public sector: The social cognitive theory perspective. Public Organization Review, 24, 1015–1036. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-024-00770-4
Lee, H.-J., & Vongkulluksn, V. W. (2022). Enhancing mathematics teacher professional learning through a contextualized professional development program. Teacher Development, 4(2), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/13664530.2022.2134195
Li, S. (2023). The effect of teacher self-efficacy, teacher resilience, and emotion regulation on teacher burnout: A mediation model. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1–7. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1185079
Li, X., Pei, X., & Zhao, J. (2025). Intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy as pathways to innovative teaching: A mixed-methods study of faculty in Chinese higher education. BioMed Central Psychology, 13(1), e859. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-025-03177-y
Mukuka, A., Balimuttajjo, S., & Mutarutinya, V. (2023). Teacher efforts towards the development of students’ mathematical reasoning skills. Heliyon, 9(4), e14789. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e14789
National Center for Education Statistics. (2023). Long-term trends in reading and mathematics achievement. Nces.ed.gov. https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=38
O’Connor, B., & Park, M. (2023). Exploring the influence of collaborative data-based decision making among teachers in professional learning communities on teaching practice. Disciplinary and Interdisciplinary Science Education Research, 5(1), 1–7. https://doi.org/10.1186/s43031-023-00086-1
Plooy, E., du, Casteleijn, D., & Franzsen, D. (2024). Personalized adaptive learning in higher education: A scoping review of key characteristics and impact on academic performance and engagement. Heliyon, 10(21), e39630. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e39630
Pozas, M., Letzel, V., Bost, N., & Reichertz, J. (2022). Confident, positive, but interested? Exploring the role of teachers’ interest in their practice of differentiated instruction. Frontiers in Education, 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2022.964341
Raley, S. K., Shogren, K. A., & Hagiwara, M. (2022). Review of existing research on coaching in inclusive, secondary classrooms. Education and Training in Autism and Developmental Disabilities, 57(2), 151–166. https://doi.org/10.2307/27236554
Reddy, L. A., Shernoff, E., & Lekwa, A. (2021). A randomized controlled trial of instructional coaching in high-poverty urban schools: Examining teacher practices and student outcomes. Journal of School Psychology, 86, 151–168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2021.04.001
Ruhter, L. C., & Karvonen, M. (2023). The impact of professional development on data-based decision-making for students with extensive support needs. Remedial and Special Education, 45(1), 44-57. https://doi.org/10.1177/07419325231164636
Ventista, O. M., & Brown, C. (2023). Teachers’ professional learning and its impact on students’ learning outcomes: Findings from a systematic review. Social Sciences & Humanities Open, 8(1), e100565. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2023.100565
Visscher, A. J. (2020). On the value of data-based decision making in education: The evidence from six intervention studies. Studies in Educational Evaluation, 69, e100899. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2020.100899
Yang, X., & Du, J. (2024). The effect of teacher self-efficacy, online pedagogical and content knowledge, and emotion regulation on teacher digital burnout: A mediation model. BioMed Central Psychology, 12(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-024-01540-z
Yuan, J., Yao, J., & Zheng, R. (2024). Driving factors of shading adjustment behavior based on social cognitive theory and structural equation modeling. Sustainability, 16(16), e7103. https://doi.org/10.3390/su16167103
