EDD 9952 Week 2 Assignment Literature Review
Literature Review
Learner and Specialization Information (to be completed by learner)
Learner Name | Name |
Learner Email | Name@gmail.com |
Learner ID Number | 0000000 |
Instructor Name | Professor Name |
Specialization | |
Program Director Name | |
Program Director Email | |
Name of Project Site | Sanders Middle School |
Name of Person Giving Authorization to Use Site | Name |
Type of Organization | Middle School |
Learner Role at Site | |
APPROVED BY INSTRUCTOR Name & Date |
Month, Year
Instructions
Use the headings below to complete the literature review. For information and examples specific to each heading, refer to the Literature Review Guide.
Introduction and Overview of the Literature Review
The consistent poor performance in mathematics in middle school is an urgent issue and has a direct impact on the long-term academic performance of the students and institutional responsibility. The recent internal assessments of Sanders Middle School showed that only 1/3 of students were on target in mathematics, which is a dismal amount against the district and state standards. Surveys, benchmark tests, and analyses showed teaching obstacles, including lack of differentiation, inconsistent use of data, and inadequate professional development in math instruction (Mukuka et al., 2023; Bellacicco et al., 2025).
The literature clearly underlines that long-term increases in student outcomes occur when educators are provided with workplace-based professional learning as well as systematic data-driven decision-making (Eryilmaz et al., 2025). Thus, the review explores empirical evidence on professional development, instructional coaching, data-informed practice, and collaborative learning as strategic interventions to reinforce teaching math to diverse learners in middle schools to bridge the gaps in achievement among different learners.
The rationale of the applied improvement project (AIP) is to improve achievement in mathematics in middle school using a systematic, evidence-based intervention that involves instructional coaching, differentiated instructional planning, and corroborative data examination. The plan will aim to enhance teacher capacity, enhance the quality of instruction, and raise the percentage of students meeting proficiency benchmarks from 32% to 45% in one academic year.
Evidence indicates that integrating instructional coaching, differentiated lesson design, and collaborative data analysis leads to measurable gains in teacher effectiveness and student mathematics achievement, particularly when interventions are sustained and data-driven (Bellacicco et al., 2025). The present writing is the phase of the advanced doctoral courses of analysis and synthesis, when the scholarly research will be revised and applied to prove and formulate the offered intervention. The experiential activity in the identified stage indicates academic integration, research literacy, and the power to correlate evidence-based approaches to institutional objectives regarding ongoing advancement.
Figure 1
Note. This figure shows the three major phases of the applied improvement project model and how the 10 steps of this model were completed within the advanced doctoral courses. The shaded sections resemble the three major phases, the circular icons resemble the 10 steps, and the line between the icons resembles the connection between each step within the appropriate phase. Retrieved from https://media.capella.edu/CourseMedia/edd8522element20223/wrapper.asp. Not in the public domain.
Problem of Practice and Background
The academic problem that the school is experiencing is of critical nature, as the school has been performing below average in mathematics, which is an indicator of a dire need to improve instructional performance. The main organizational problem is persistent underperformance in middle school mathematics at the identified school, where only 32% of students are at the state proficiency level, which is significantly lower than both district and state levels (District Math Benchmark Report, Fall 2024). The performance gap indicates systemic instructional and organizational obstacles such as low levels of teacher content knowledge and math pedagogy confidence, ineffective use of differentiated instruction, and irregular use of assessment data to make formative decisions (Bellacicco et al., 2025; Mukuka et al., 2023; Ruhter and Karvonen, 2023).
Prior remediation attempts, such as optional tutoring and standardized test preparation, demonstrated low participation and minimal alignment to classroom practice, further exacerbating gaps in foundational skills like fractions, algebraic reasoning, and multistep problem solving (Ruhter & Karvonen, 2023; Plooy et al., 2024). Instructional issues are exacerbated by contextual factors such as more than three-quarters of students being economically disadvantaged and a diverse student body and special education populations, which underscores the importance of job-embedded and content-oriented professional learning and systematic data-use procedures to facilitate equitable outcomes (National Center for Education Statistics, 2023; Kelty and Wakabayashi, 2020). Such complex obstacles should be tackled using evidence-based professional growth and data-driven teaching to enhance math proficiency and eliminate achievement gaps.
The studies support the idea that the lack of professional development and a lack of teacher collaboration are paramount root causes of poor mathematics performance, especially in high-poverty schools. An example is the study by Lee and Vongkulluksn (2022), who discovered that shorter-term, content-related professional learning, which lacked sustained content-specific learning, was associated with weaker instructional coherence and reduced student gains in math. In a similar manner, O’Connor and Park (2023) stressed that collaborative professional communities are essential in enhancing teacher efficacy and student achievement through mutual instructional practices and data-driven reflection.
The barriers identified in the context of the chosen school, where more than three-quarters of students are economically disadvantaged and the rates of chronic absenteeism are higher than those in the district (National Center for Education Statistics, 2023), exacerbate disparities in access to quality education and regular learning hours. On a national level, fewer than 40 percent of eighth-grade students are proficient in mathematics, highlighting a systemic issue of instruction that mirrors the results of the school in question (Harris, 2025). Therefore, it is urgent that an intervention that focuses on professional development that is structured, collaborative, and sustained is necessary to reduce the compounding effects of poverty, insufficient teacher capacity, and attendance issues on the school achievement gap.
Organization and Purpose of the Literature Review
The aim of the AIP is to enhance mathematics performance in grades 6-8 at the identified school by introducing a teacher-focused intervention that includes job-based professional development, teacher coaching, and collaborative data analysis to increase the proficiency level from 32 percent to 45 percent in a single academic year. The literature review has been divided into four main sections that collectively form the evidence base of this initiative. The theoretical background examines the theory of adult learning and change, which underpins effective professional development.
The problem of practice section discusses the research on the factors that lead to low math achievement in high-need and rural schools. The intervention section examines the evidence on the use of professional development, coaching, and data-driven instruction as strategies that can be used to enhance outcomes. Lastly, the methods section identifies the research designs and evaluation strategies that can be applied in school improvement initiatives. Collectively, these sections offer the theoretical, empirical, and methodological basis that can be used to guide and evaluate the implementation of the AIP.
Library Search Process
The search of the literature was conducted through thorough access to peer-reviewed journals and other scholarly sources in various databases accessible in the Capella University Library, such as ERIC (Education Resources Information Center), ProQuest Education Database, Education Source, and SAGE Journals. Additional searches were done in Google Scholar and ResearchGate to locate open-access and recent literature that was published between 2010 and 2025 in the areas related to mathematics teaching and learning, professional growth, and school improvement based on data. Search strategies and inclusion criteria were based on the use of Boolean operators and the emphasis on empirical studies, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses on middle school education, teacher capacity building, and the results of instruction in mathematics. The search terms applied in the search were as follows to ensure a thorough review:
- mathematics achievement AND middle school students
- teacher professional development AND instructional coaching
- data-driven decision making in education
- differentiated instruction AND student performance
- equity in mathematics education
- job-embedded learning AND teacher efficacy
- school improvement interventions AND student outcomes
Theoretical Foundation for the Applied Improvement Project
The Applied Improvement Project (AIP) is based on the Social Cognitive Theory (SCT) developed by Albert Bandura that underlines the dynamic interplay between personal beliefs, behaviors, and environmental conditions in determining learning and performance. SCT is a relevant approach to this project because it bridges the gap between teacher professional development and classroom practice and student achievement. The emphasis of the AIP on job-based professional growth, instructional coaching, and shared data analysis indicates the principles of the theory of social learning, modeling, and self-efficacy as the key factors in the ongoing change in instruction.
Social Cognitive Theory
The specified theory presents three key constructs (reciprocal determinism, observational learning, and self-efficacy) that perfectly correspond with the design of the chosen intervention and the outcomes that should be expected. Reciprocal determinism is the perception that teacher learning is a process that is built due to the constant communication between beliefs, professional action, and the school environment (Hosseini et al., 2025). Observational learning introduces the idea of how the proficiency of instruction can be improved by teachers through modeling, expert coaching, and peer feedback. Self-efficacy, or the perception of an individual’s ability to arrange and carry out actions necessary when the time comes to achieve the desired outcomes, is the key driving force in the intervention (Hosseini et al., 2025). With increased self-efficacy, teachers are likely to embrace new models of teaching, persevere, and create a positive influence on student performance.
The use of social cognitive theory in the improvement project creates a clear connection between professional learning experiences and a change in behavior among the teachers. Instructional coaching and collective data analysis sessions provide systematic opportunities to participate in the observation-based learning, feedback, and mastery experiences that are the most significant processes to develop self-efficacy and improve instructional practice. The theory underlines the anticipation that teacher self-efficacy can be improved with the help of long-term, context-based professional development, which will result in better mathematics teaching and quantifiable student outcomes (Al-Dokhny et al., 2021). As such, SCT offers the conceptual framework to design, implement, and evaluate the intervention that will support the capacity of teachers and address the mathematics achievement gap.
Uses of Social Cognitive Theory
Recent education research has greatly applied the SCT in research to determine the interaction effects of self-efficacy, social modeling, and environmental factors on teacher performance and student results. The article about the linkage between teacher self-efficacy, resilience, and burnout among Chinese instructors was one of the latest articles that reported that a rise in the efficacy level foretold a rise in engagement in work and a decline in emotional exhaustion (Li, 2023).
The study supported the assumption made by SCT that the relationship between the context and behavioral persistence is mediated by efficacy beliefs. Gordon et al. (2022) synthesized 29 empirical studies of the topic of teacher self-efficacy in the context of curriculum and assessment reform in a systematic review. Using the conceptual framework of SCT, the authors have placed an emphasis on how the mastery experiences, such as classroom experimentation, vicarious learning through modeled lessons, and repeated verbal persuasion by instructional coaches, were all implicated in improving teachers’ readiness to change.
The study found that technology acceptance intention was predicted by the self-efficacy of instructors and social factors, with mastery and vicarious experience as mediators in the correlations. Theoretical explanation of how modeling and guided practice help to adopt the new tools was provided by SCT constructs, which are consistent with professional-development interventions characterized by the creation of efficacy by observation and feedback. Johnson (2024) presented a case study of a data-driven coaching model that was designed to enhance the instructional fidelity of a teacher and classroom interactions. The intervention provided cyclic modeling, practice, and feedback, all of which were related to SCT sources of efficacy. Results showed a significant change in implementation fidelity and lasting instructional change. The researcher contextualized the gains observed as a result of enhanced self-efficacy achieved by mastery and verbal persuasion, and affirmed determinism between individual beliefs and professional action.
New findings still confirm the applicability of social cognitive theory as a guiding paradigm in comprehending teacher learning, professional development, and instructional decision-making in modern educational contexts. Khan et al. (2024) investigated the influence of data-use confidence of teachers on instructional decision-making in various schools. More targeted and frequent instructional adjustments were reported by teachers with greater confidence, especially in the context of collaborative structures, like data-review and coaching teams. The research placed data-use confidence in the context of SCT and viewed the discovered theory as a specialized variant of self-efficacy.
Findings highlighted the interplay between personal beliefs and environmental affordances, which is central to the focus of SCT on the two-way relationship between behavior, cognition, and context. The studies combined support the idea that the constructs of mastery experience, observational learning, and reciprocal determinism of SCT remain a strong explanatory framework of teacher professional learning, coaching effectiveness, and instructional innovation. The data support the idea that efficacy is the key that connects professional-development experiences to behavioral and organizational outcomes.
Similarities in Theory Application
In these and other modern uses, there were patterns of uniformity in the interpretation and operationalization of SCT. All of the studies placed self-efficacy at the center of the mediating construct between professional support and behavior change, which is a reflection of the SCT statement that high efficacy beliefs lead to persistence, flexibility, and resilience in difficult situations (Gordon et al., 2022; Li, 2023; Khan et al., 2024). Mastery experiences, practice, and coaching cycles continuously yielded quantifiable gains in teacher performance and confidence, whereas vicarious learning and verbal persuasion with peer modeling and positive feedback supported the preferred behaviors (Li et al., 2025).
In addition, both studies supported the principle of reciprocal determinism of SCT: that teacher behavior and environmental supports have a mutual impact on each other. The social contexts that enhanced the efficacy gains and maintained change were collaborative professional communities, leadership encouragement, and access to performance data. Taken together, the studies reviewed indicate a commonality in the application of SCT to the educational improvement process, which highlights the relevance of the theory in the future to inform the implementation of interventions aimed at improving teacher capacity, instructional quality, and student achievement.
Differences in Theory Application
All the reviewed studies were founded on the social cognition theory, although the interpretation and application of the key constructs to various settings varied. The article by Li (2023) was dedicated to the significance of SCT as a psychological process that mostly influences emotional and motivational processes in teachers and determined self-efficacy as a predictor and buffer of burnout. It was a traditional intrapersonal focus on efficacy in the belief system of the individual as the main factor of resilience and little regard to the mutual environmental effects. Instead, Gordon et al. (2022) embraced a more comprehensive approach of a social and systemic framework and focused on the interplay between collective efficacy and institutional supports within professional learning communities. The theory broadened the concept and was more concerned with collective mastery experiences and not just the thought process.
Recent studies have extended the use of social cognitive theory by incorporating the theory with complementary models to respond to the changing educational and technological environments. Li et al. (2025) took it a step further and integrated SCT with the Technology Acceptance Model, and therefore, adapted the constructs to the digital learning environment. The authors redefined vicarious learning and verbal persuasion as elements of technology-based training and peer influence, whereby the authors embraced SCT constructs to establish a behavioral approach rather than actual realization.
The identified cross-theoretical adaptation was the contextual change towards the adoption of innovations, for which SCT lacked behavioral foundations, yet it centered on the attitudinal aspects. In the identified application, reciprocal determinism was explicit due to the active engagement of the coaching interventions and the teacher’s behavioral outcomes, which meant that it was highly consistent with the original assumptions of the identified theory.
There is also a scholarly interest in the flexibility of social cognitive theory in the instructional and organizational contexts, highlighting the contextual interpretation of the main constructs. Khan et al. (2024) viewed SCT through the prism of a data-driven instructional model, the interpretation of which is based on the belief in confidence in the interpretation of data and making a decision, not on the overall ability to teach. This adaptation reframed the construct contextually in terms of specialized efficacy in evidence-based practices. Khan et al. (2024) focused on analytical competence as the behavioral manifestation of efficacy, as opposed to Li (2023), who emphasized emotional resilience.
These differences indicate that the operationalization of the constructs of SCT depends on professional focus: emotional, cognitive, behavioral, or technological. Taken together, the studies indicate that although SCT offers a common theoretical foundation, the implementation is very flexible. The researchers tend to focus on different elements (self-efficacy, reciprocal determinism, observational learning, or environmental influence) based on the phenomenon they are studying, thus showing the flexibility of the theory in both educational and organizational contexts.
Review of the Literature Related to the Problem of Practice
First Theme or Similarity That Unites a Cluster Based on the Problem of Practice (Replace with the Name of the Theme)
Second Theme or Similarity That Unites a Cluster Based on the Problem of Practice (Replace with the Name of the Theme)
Critique and Synthesis
Review of the Literature Related to the Intervention or Solution
First Theme (Replace with the Name of the Theme)
Second Theme (Replace with the Name of the Theme)
Critique and Synthesis
Review of the Literature Related to the Methods
Literature Review Summary
References
Al-Dokhny, A., Drwish, A., Alyoussef, I., & Al-Abdullatif, A. (2021). Students’ intentions to use distance education platforms: An investigation into expanding the technology acceptance model through social cognitive theory. Electronics, 10(23), e2992. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics10232992
Bellacicco, R., Capone, F., Sorrentino, C., & Di Martino, V. (2025). The role of active breaks and curriculum-based active breaks in enhancing executive functions and math performance, and in reducing math anxiety in primary school children: A systematic review. Education Sciences, 15(1), 47. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci15010047
Eryilmaz, N., Kennedy, A. I., Strietholt, R., & Johansson, S. (2025). Teacher job satisfaction: International evidence on the role of school working conditions and teacher characteristics. Studies in Educational Evaluation, 86(4), 101474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2025.101474
Gordon, D., Blundell, C., Mills, R., & Bourke, T. (2022). Teacher self-efficacy and reform: A systematic literature review. The Australian Educational Researcher, 50, 801–821. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13384-022-00526-3
Hosseini, Z., Tavafian, S., Ahmadi, O., & Maghbouli, R. (2025). Assessing the impact of a social cognitive theory-based educational intervention on ergonomic behaviors: a randomized controlled trial utilizing a learning-by-doing approach. BioMed Central Public Health, 25(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-025-24533-y
Johnson, H. N., Lo, Y., & Nichols, M. E. (2024). Data-driven coaching model to support teachers’ implementation of opportunities to respond. Educational Research and Development Journal, 27(2), 1–26. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1462677
Kelty, N. E., & Wakabayashi, T. (2020). Family engagement in schools: Parent, educator, and community perspectives. SAGE Open, 10(4), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244020973024
Khan, N. A., Maialeh, R., Akhtar, M., & Ramzan, M. (2024). The role of AI self-efficacy in religious contexts in public sector: The social cognitive theory perspective. Public Organization Review, 24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-024-00770-4
Li, S. (2023). The effect of teacher self-efficacy, teacher resilience, and emotion regulation on teacher burnout: A mediation model. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1–7. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1185079
Li, X., Pei, X., & Zhao, J. (2025). Intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy as pathways to innovative teaching: A mixed-methods study of faculty in Chinese higher education. BioMed Central Psychology, 13(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-025-03177-y
Mukuka, A., Balimuttajjo, S., & Mutarutinya, V. (2023). Teacher efforts towards the development of students’ mathematical reasoning skills. Heliyon, 9(4), e14789. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e14789
Plooy, E. du, Casteleijn, D., & Franzsen, D. (2024). Personalized adaptive learning in higher education: A scoping review of key characteristics and impact on academic performance and engagement. Heliyon, 10(21), e39630. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e39630
Ruhter, L. C., & Karvonen, M. (2023). The impact of professional development on data-based decision-making for students with extensive support needs. Remedial and Special Education, 45(1), 074193252311646. https://doi.org/10.1177/07419325231164636
Visscher, A. J. (2020). On the value of data-based decision making in education: The evidence from six intervention studies. Studies in Educational Evaluation, 69(3), 100899. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2020.100899
Yuan, J., Yao, J., & Zheng, R. (2024). Driving factors of shading adjustment behavior based on social cognitive theory and structural equation modeling. Sustainability, 16(16), e7103. https://doi.org/10.3390/su16167103

