EDD 9952 Week 9 Assignment Applied Improvement Project Action Plan
Applied Improvement Project Action Plan
Learner Name | Name |
Learner E-mail | |
Learner ID Number | |
Instructor Name | |
Specialization | |
Program Director Name | |
Program Director E-mail | |
Name of Project Site | |
Name of Person Giving Authorization to Use Site | |
Type of Organization | |
Learner Role at Site | |
PROVISIONAL APPROVAL BY INSTRUCTOR Name & Date | |
Date of IRB APPROVAL |
Oct 2024
Instructions
Use the headings below to complete the AIP Action Plan. For information and examples specific to each heading, refer to the Action Plan Guide document.
INTRODUCTION
This applied improvement project (AIP) seeks to increase mathematics achievement in a South Carolina public school in a rural context by implementing specific, evidence-based interventions that increase teacher instructional capacity through job-embedded professional development (JEP), job-embedded instructional coaching (JEI), and collaborative data-driven planning. An improvement project action plan provides strategic direction, accountability, can be used to allocate resources, systematically track progress, and provides evidence-based direction for the achievement of measurable quality outcomes (Liu, 2024). The stage is still in the planning stage (Phase 2) of the AIP model and is targeted towards defining specific interventions and the implementation process for these interventions to address the identified organizational issue.
The AIP Model (Figure 1) provides a clear, concise, three-part structure of problem diagnosis, planning, and implementation and evaluation, broken into 10 sequential steps, that can be used by practitioners to identify the problem and develop a solution, implement and evaluate the solution, and assess the outcomes. The organizational issue is that mathematics performance continues to be low in grades 6-8; 32 of 100 students are performing at the same level as the district (56 out of 100) and state (65 out of 100) (District Math Benchmark Report, Fall 2024). The low performance can be used as an indicator of the difference between what is actually achieved and the expected performance, which is a gap of 58 percent.
These root causes include teachers’ lack of content knowledge, pedagogical confidence, inconsistency of differentiated instruction, and the use of data and math-specific PD. The best answer is a combination of long-term professional development and weekly data team meetings where teachers will be able to collaborate to grow their capacity, the quality of instruction, and the student achievement rise from 32 percent on the initial assessment to 45 percent after one year.
Figure 1
Applied Improvement Project Model
Note. The figure shows the three major phases of the Applied Improvement Project Model and how the 10 steps of the model were completed within the Advanced doctoral courses. The shaded sections resemble the three major phases, the circular icons resemble the 10 steps, and the line between the icons resembles the connection between each step within the appropriate phase. Retrieved from https://media.capella.edu/CourseMedia/edd8522element20223/wrapper.asp. Not in the public domain.
Purpose of the Project
The goal of the project is to establish math-specific professional development along with organized weekly data team meetings, which take place in partnership with each other to improve the performance of mathematics for middle school students in grades 6-8. The organizational need addressed by the intervention is: Currently, 32% of students are not proficient on the State’s mathematics standards, which is significantly less than the district and state standards (District Math Benchmark Report, Fall 2024). Root-cause analysis revealed that a deficiency in teacher content knowledge, low confidence in math pedagogy, inconsistency in using assessment data to plan instruction, and lack of differentiated instruction are major factors in continuing underperformance in students.
Participants and Stakeholders
The implemented improvement project has different categories of participants and stakeholders, which are vital in the implementation and support of the intervention to enhance mathematics achievement in middle schools. While all the participants are stakeholders with an interest in improving students’ outcomes, not all stakeholders will have direct involvement in the intervention activities or in data collection. Defining the difference between participants and stakeholders equates to proper role assignment, ethical boundaries, and efficient use of resources throughout the project lifecycle (Guise et al., 2024). The roles enable understanding of the roles to be taken to develop clear implementation, accountability, and proper collaboration in the project stages.
Participants
The AIP is going to comprise around 8 mathematics teachers of grades 6-8 who will be directly involved in the intervention procedures and will, in turn, be the main data sources associated with the assessment of the implementation and the results. The teachers will receive math professional development, weekly joint math data team meetings, math observation and feedback, and math coaching activity, and then will implement a variety of math teaching methods based on the math performance data.
The size of the participant group is also based on the number of middle school math teachers at the site and meets the criteria of qualitative analysis that presupposes 5-10 participants to conduct a thorough analysis of the implementation fidelity and perceptions. The sample size will allow for meaningful data to be gathered through the interview, survey, and observation of classrooms without being too large for the staff resources of the school (Xu et al., 2025). The teachers are selected as the participants because they have direct responsibility for the delivery of maths instruction, and teaching ability is the primary instrument to improve student achievement outcomes.
Stakeholders
There will be several key stakeholders within the school community: the school principal, assistant principal, instructional coach, district curriculum coordinator, students in grades 6-8, and parents/families. Instructional leaders are the school principal and assistant principal, who will provide administrative support, resources, time to work cooperatively, and fidelity in enacting the program. The instructional coach supports professional development, classroom observations, teacher feedback, and data analysis (Schladant et al., 2025). The district curriculum coordinator will make sure that the intervention aligns with the district-level mathematics standards, policies, and assessment protocols.
The expected positive outcomes are improvements in mathematics performance and participation (Weatherton et al., 2024), with some of the stakeholders affected being students as the end users of better-quality instruction. The stakeholders will be parents/families who will be involved and will encourage students to be successful in their studies. The stakeholders will be involved in the planning process, get updates on the progress, and be involved in the sustainability planning process, but will not be directly involved in the intervention activities or in the process of data collection.
Description of the Applied Improvement Project
The improvement project intervention is a mathematics professional development program and formal weekly collaborative data team meetings that will support the instructional capacity of the teachers and increase mathematics achievement in the middle school following a 4-5 week implementation period. The interventions will have a specific focus on the needs identified in the needs assessment: teacher lack of content knowledge, lack of confidence in math pedagogy, lack of using assessment data for instructional planning, lack of differentiated instruction, and lack of cohesion of grade-level teams.
The intervention will be implemented in three elements that are related and given in sequence and repeated. To begin with, educators will attend job-based professional development activities about math-based instructional methods such as the use of differentiated instruction, formative assessment, and algebraic reasoning pedagogy in line with the state standards of mathematics (Schladant et al., 2025). The professional development sessions will be conducted during a specific amount of professional learning time, and two preliminary sessions (90 minutes each) will be held during Week 1 to introduce the initial knowledge and teaching expectations. The instructional coach will provide the content to the district curriculum coordinator based on the research-supported procedures and examples of effective math instruction. Teachers will be given instructional resource packets, differentiation planning guides, and access to web-based manipulatives, as well as visual aids to support their classrooms.
Secondly, teachers will attend weekly data team meetings, which will be structured from week 2 to week 5. The meetings will be 60 minutes long with a regular data protocol to review the student performance data on the benchmark assessment and formative classroom assessment, identify patterns of student misconceptions or missing skills, plan for differentiated instructional responses, and monitor the impact of the changes in instruction on student learning (Lipnevich et al., 2025). The instructional coach will facilitate the meetings in a consistent format using a common data analysis model that will keep grade-level groups consistent and enable teachers to be accountable to the students in their classes. Resources will be provided, such as an agenda, data templates, and a protocol guide that can be used to structure discussions and document instructional decisions.
Third, the intervention includes ongoing cycles of instructional coaching that include classroom observations, individual feedback meetings, and shared planning. Since week 2, the instructional coach will make regular classroom walkthroughs (15-20 min) to see how new strategies have been implemented, and timely feedback conversations (20-30 min) will be based on specific instructional practices, like questioning strategies, student engagement strategies, or differentiation strategies. The minimum number of coaching cycles that a teacher will get is at least two within the 4-5 week-long period, supplemented by other assistance at any time (Motto, 2021). Reflective dialogue will be included in coaching conversations, which will enable teachers to evaluate their practice and set goals aimed at their future progress.
The order of implementation is logical and progresses to the teachers’ capacity building. The first week focuses on the basic professional development to ensure a shared set of expectations and the basic instructional strategies are introduced. Weeks 2- 5 are characterised by implementing continuous data team-building sessions and parallel coaching cycles, creating a feedback loop of teacher learning of new strategies and implementation in a classroom, data review of students as a group, coaching of individual teachers, and adapting it based on the learning evidence collected from students (Merwe et al., 2024). The iterative design follows the principles of Social Cognitive Theory of observational learning, mastery experiences, and reciprocal determinism between teachers’ beliefs, instructional behavior, and organizational supports to improve continuously (Islam et al., 2023).
Resources needed for the implementation include some professional learning time (approximately 6 hours total, over 45 weeks), some guaranteed collaboration time (4 hours total), some instructional coach availability to facilitate and observe classrooms (approximately 1012 hours a week), access to student assessment data from the district data management system, some print instructional resources and planning forms (estimated cost: a thousand dollars), and some online subscription to math-specific instructional tools or manipulative interfaces (estimated cost: a hundred thousand dollars). Human resources include an instructional coach, a district curriculum coordinator during the first rollout of PD, and school administrators to ensure secure time and fidelity of implementation (Wells, 2024). Any additional funding to the current school or district funds is not anticipated to be required for this intervention, as the intervention will leverage existing staffing and will strategically plan the best use of existing professional learning time and spaces.
The expected outcomes of the intervention are identified in the needs assessment statements and are measurable changes in the mathematical proficiency of the students and the ability of the teachers to teach mathematics. Teacher content knowledge and teacher instructional confidence will increase as evidenced by pre-intervention and post-intervention teacher self-efficacy surveys, and teacher implementation fidelity of differentiated instructional strategies on coaching observation rubrics that share the fidelity of implementation of differentiated instructional strategies (Yang and Du, 2024).
If the leadership process facilitates weekly, shared data meetings between teachers, then data-based instructional planning will be improved, the number of differentiated lesson plans will grow, the quality of differentiated lesson plans will be improved, the number and quality of instructional adjustments recorded in data team meeting notes will increase, and the teachers will report increased confidence in using assessment data to inform instruction. In case the intervention is carried out with fidelity in all elements, then the level of student mathematics proficiency will rise by 32 percent on benchmark measures that are given at the end of the intervention period to a target of 45 percent mathematics proficiency (District Math Benchmark Report, Fall 2024).
Implementation Plan
The applied improvement project implementation plan provides particular activities, tasks, parties in charge, schedules, and documentation of the completion required to implement the math-specific professional development program, accompanied by the systematic weekly collaborative meetings on the data team. The step-by-step plan will be used to implement the entire process systematically over the 4-5 week intervention period and will also offer accountability frameworks to evaluate the progress of the intervention in improving mathematics performance in middle school. The plan will be structured sequentially, starting with the activities involved in pre-intervention preparation, the activities involved in intervention delivery, and finally with the activities involved in evaluation as a way of evaluating the fidelity of the implementation and its results.
Table 1
Implementation Plan
ACTIVITY/INTERVENTION | TASKS | WHO | TIMELINE | DEADLINE | EVIDENCE of COMPLETION (Outputs) |
Pre-Intervention Preparation Activities | |||||
Secure administrative approval and resource allocation | Present implementation plan to principal and assistant principal; obtain commitment for protected collaboration time, instructional coach availability, and materials budget | Applied researcher, Principal, Assistant Principal | Week before implementation (Pre-Week 1) | 5 days before Week 1 | Signed memorandum of understanding; approved budget allocation; confirmed meeting schedule |
Recruit and inform teacher participants. | Distribute informed consent documents; conduct information session explaining intervention purpose, activities, time commitment, and voluntary participation; answer questions | Applied researcher, Instructional Coach | Week prior to implementation (Pre-Week 1) | 3 days before Week 1 | Signed informed consent forms from 8 teacher participants; attendance roster from information session |
Prepare professional development materials and resources. | Develop PowerPoint presentations, instructional resource packets, differentiation planning templates, data analysis protocols; secure digital subscriptions to math manipulative platforms; print materials | Instructional Coach, District Curriculum Coordinator | 2 weeks prior to implementation | 1 week before Week 1 | Completed presentation materials; printed resource packets (8 copies); active digital platform accounts; data protocol templates |
Administer pre-intervention assessments | Distribute and collect teacher self-efficacy surveys measuring confidence in math instruction, differentiation, and data use; administer baseline student benchmark assessments | Applied researcher, Math Teachers | Week prior to implementation (Pre-Week 1) | 2 days before Week 1 | Completed teacher surveys (8 responses); baseline student assessment data entered into data management system |
Schedule coaching observations and data team meetings | Create observation schedule for Weeks 2-5; reserve conference room for weekly data team meetings; send calendar invitations to all participants | Instructional Coach, School Secretary | Week prior to implementation (Pre-Week 1) | 1 day before Week 1 | Published observation schedule; confirmed meeting space reservations; sent calendar invitations |
During-Intervention Activities | |||||
Professional Development Session 1: Differentiated Instruction in Mathematics | Deliver a 90-minute workshop on differentiation strategies specific to middle school math (flexible grouping, tiered assignments, formative assessment techniques); model instructional strategies; distribute planning templates. | Instructional Coach, District Curriculum Coordinator | Week 1, Day 1 | End of Week 1, Day 1 | Attendance sign-in sheet; completed participant feedback forms; distributed resource packets and templates |
Professional Development Session 2: Data-Driven Instructional Planning | Deliver 90-minute workshop on using benchmark and formative assessment data to identify learning gaps, plan targeted interventions, and monitor student progress; introduce data team protocol. | Instructional Coach | Week 1, Day 3 | End of Week 1, Day 3 | Attendance sign-in sheet; completed participant feedback forms; sample data analysis artifacts created during session |
Weekly Collaborative Data Team Meeting 1 | Facilitate a 60-minute meeting following data protocol: review baseline benchmark data, identify common student misconceptions in targeted skill areas, collaboratively plan differentiated instructional responses for upcoming week. | Instructional Coach (facilitator), Math Teachers (participants) | Week 2, designated day | End of Week 2 | Completed meeting agenda and notes; documented instructional decisions; differentiated lesson plans for following week |
Instructional Coaching Cycle 1: Classroom Observations Round 1 | Conduct 15-20 minute classroom walkthroughs for each teacher (8 observations total) focusing on implementation of differentiation strategies from PD Session 1; document observations using coaching rubric. | Instructional Coach | Week 2 | End of Week 2 | Completed observation rubrics for 8 teachers; scheduled feedback appointments |
Instructional Coaching Cycle 1: Feedback Conversations Round 1 | Conduct individual 20-30 minute feedback sessions with each teacher to discuss observation findings, celebrate strengths, identify growth areas, and set instructional goals; use reflective questioning protocol. | Instructional Coach, Math Teachers | Week 3, first half | Mid-Week 3 | Completed feedback conversation notes for 8 teachers; documented teacher-set goals |
Weekly Collaborative Data Team Meeting 2 | Facilitate 60-minute meeting: review formative assessment data from Week 2 instruction, analyze effectiveness of implemented differentiated strategies, adjust instructional plans based on student response data | Instructional Coach (facilitator), Math Teachers (participants) | Week 3, designated day | End of Week 3 | Completed meeting agenda and notes; documented instructional adjustments; revised lesson plans |
Instructional Coaching Cycle 2: Classroom Observations Round 2 | Conduct 15-20 minute classroom walkthroughs for each teacher (8 observations total) focusing on data-informed instructional adjustments and progress toward individual teacher goals. | Instructional Coach | Week 3, second half | End of Week 3 | Completed observation rubrics for 8 teachers; scheduled feedback appointments |
Instructional Coaching Cycle 2: Feedback Conversations Round 2 | Conduct individual 20-30 minute feedback sessions with each teacher to discuss observation findings, progress toward goals, refinement of instructional strategies | Instructional Coach, Math Teachers | Week 4, first half | Mid-Week 4 | Completed feedback conversation notes for 8 teachers; documented progress on goals |
Weekly Collaborative Data Team Meeting 3 | Facilitate a 60-minute meeting: review ongoing formative assessment data, identify persistent student learning challenges, plan targeted small-group interventions and reteaching strategies | Instructional Coach (facilitator), Math Teachers (participants) | Week 4, designated day | End of Week 4 | Completed meeting agenda and notes; documented intervention plans; small-group planning materials |
Weekly Collaborative Data Team Meeting 4 | Facilitate 60-minute meeting: review comprehensive student performance data from Weeks 1-4, analyze trends in student growth, discuss sustainability of implemented practices, prepare for post-intervention assessment | Instructional Coach (facilitator), Math Teachers (participants) | Week 5, designated day | End of Week 5 | Completed meeting agenda and notes; trend analysis documentation; sustainability planning notes |
Evaluation Activities | |||||
Administer post-intervention student assessments | Distribute and administer benchmark assessments to all students in grades 6-8; score and enter data into data management system for comparison with baseline | Math Teachers, Applied researcher | Week 5, final days | End of Week 5 | Completed student assessments; scored and entered post-intervention data |
Administer post-intervention teacher surveys | Distribute and collect teacher self-efficacy surveys measuring confidence in math instruction, differentiation, and data use; compare with pre-intervention baseline | Applied researcher | Week 5, final day | End of Week 5 | Completed teacher surveys (8 responses); comparative analysis document |
Conduct participant interviews | Schedule and conduct individual 30-45 minute semi-structured interviews with each teacher participant to gather qualitative data on perceptions of intervention effectiveness, implementation challenges, and impact on instructional practice | Applied researcher | Week 6 (post-intervention) | End of Week 6 | Completed interviews with 8 participants; audio recordings and transcripts |
Analyze coaching observation data | Review all coaching rubrics from observation cycles; calculate fidelity scores; identify patterns in implementation quality and teacher growth | Applied researcher, Instructional Coach | Week 6 (post-intervention) | End of Week 6 | Completed fidelity analysis report; summary of teacher growth trends |
Analyze data team artifacts | Review meeting notes, instructional planning documents, and evidence of data-informed decision-making from all four data team meetings | Applied researcher | Week 6 (post-intervention) | End of Week 6 | Completed analysis of collaborative data use quality and frequency |
Conduct stakeholder feedback surveys (optional) | Distribute brief surveys to principal, assistant principal, and instructional coach to gather perspectives on implementation process and organizational impact. | Applied researcher | Week 6 (post-intervention) | End of Week 6 | Completed stakeholder surveys; summary of feedback |
Synthesize findings and prepare preliminary report | Analyze all qualitative data sources; compare pre- and post-intervention outcomes; document implementation successes and challenges; prepare draft report with recommendations | Applied researcher | Weeks 7-8 (post-intervention) | End of Week 8 | Completed preliminary evaluation report with data tables, charts, and narrative findings |
Collaboration with Participants and Stakeholders
The ability to work effectively with Participants and Stakeholders. Effective working relationships with Participants and Stakeholders. Participants’ and stakeholders’ involvement in the implementation of the applied improvement project will be essential to remain faithful to the project, engage in discussions about issues, and keep up the momentum and commitment. The teacher respondents will be collaborating closely with each other (weekly data team meetings) and will collectively review student performance data, share a range of instructional strategies, and plan for a range of differentiation based on the learning gaps identified (Li, 2025).
The collaborative design develops collective efficacy and collective accountability and changes the practice of individual classrooms to coordinated instructional improvements (Wullschleger et al., 2025). The instructional coach will also be a cooperative partner throughout intervention, co-planning instruction with teachers, modeling instruction, and engaging in reflective conversations during feedback that maintain and sustain the teacher’s knowledge and growth.
The stakeholder cooperation will take place mostly at the planning and evaluation stages. The principal and the assistant principal shall be involved in pre-intervention planning sessions to mobilize the resources, create expectations to be met in the implementation, and coordinate the intervention with the school improvement objectives. The instructional coach will also provide weekly brief progress updates to keep track of the implementation and solve any logistical or time-schedule problems (Ivarsson et al., 2025).
The district’s curriculum coordinator will be a part of developing and implementing initial professional development programs and ensure that these are aligned with the district’s mathematics standards and mathematics curriculum expectations. Parents and families will be informed of intervention through a parent communication letter during Week 1, such as: Sending a parent communication letter home, informing parents of the importance of the school to improve math teaching, and asking parents to support student learning at home. Teachers will facilitate informal classroom conversations to introduce the student voice and allow students to share their experience of the new ins, and to provide feedback on how comprehensible and interesting the lesson is.
Strategies for Keeping Participants and Stakeholders Informed
Communication during the intervention process shall be effective and ongoing to keep all the participants and stakeholders informed of the progress, acknowledge success, and address issues in an open manner. Each week, the instructional coach will email teacher participants following each data team meeting with a summary of key decisions, action items, and future coaching observation schedules as documented by the data team (Glover et al., 2023).
A digital folder to keep all the meeting notes, data analysis template, teaching resources, and planning documents will be created to ensure that everyone involved in the collaborative teamwork process has access to these at all times while also ensuring transparency (Zamiri & Esmaeili, 2024). The applied researcher will submit a report to the principal and assistant principal every 2 weeks, reporting on progress in implementation; attendance; early observations of the changes in instruction; and challenges that may not be available.
Specific messages will also be provided to the non-direct participants at key points of the intervention. The parent mid-intervention update letter will occur in week 3 and will include specific language to pass along to parents about instructional progress to date and specific suggestions for supporting math learning at home (e.g., reviewing homework, problem-solving discussions at home, and reinforcement of growth mindset language) (Nobis & Caparroso, 2024).
A district curriculum coordinator will receive a comprehensive progress report at the end of Week 5 that will include attendance for professional development, district data team involvement, patterns of coaching, and initial student performance data. The report will impact decisions at the district level about expansion or modification of the intervention to other schools. Preliminary findings will be the focus of a brief presentation to all stakeholders in Week 7, which will allow for providing feedback, asking questions, and planning sustainably after the first intervention period.
Anticipated Challenges During Implementation
Some of the problems that may occur during the implementation of the improvement project are predictable; hence, planning and reacting proactively and adaptively are essential. Time is another challenging consideration because teachers are already busy with teaching, conferences, administration, etc. (Javed and Akhter, 2024). Second, teaching team preparedness and confidence may vary, with different teachers participating in the intervention having different levels of mathematical content knowledge, pedagogy, and knowledge of data-driven instruction (DDI) (Quiroz, 2025).
Based on the needs assessment, over 72% of teachers felt they were not yet prepared to effectively use differentiation strategies; therefore, they may not feel the need to learn new strategies to do so. The instructional coach will strive to surmount this challenge by differentiating the amount of coaching support offered to teachers based on their need for each type and will provide more modeling or co-teaching to the teachers who need it, while celebrating small gains to build confidence and motivation in teachers.
Third, the student attendance and engagement issues that originated from the high-poverty situation can also impact the impact of the intervention, as chronic absenteeism reduces hours of teaching and learning interruptions. Fourth, access to data and technological challenges can interfere with collaborative data analysis in case the benchmark assessment results are not fast enough or in case of technical issues in the data management system of the district (Paulus et al., 2023).
The applied researcher will collaborate with the district data office to make sure that the data is delivered at the right time and will make reserve data spreadsheets that can be available to teachers in case of any problems with the system. Finally, issues of sustainability may arise when the participants wonder about the sustainability of the coaching support and collaborative structures beyond the intervention period. Some planning will be done in the evaluation stage about how the practices will be maintained, and the external applied researcher in the evaluation stage could take over instructional leadership roles with the internal researchers.
Planning Questions
- What specific dates and times will be designated for weekly data team meetings to ensure consistent teacher participation without conflicting with other school commitments or faculty meetings?
- How will substitute coverage or planning period adjustments be arranged to allow the instructional coach to conduct classroom observations and feedback conversations during the school day without disrupting student instruction?
- What is the process and timeline for accessing student benchmark assessment data from the district data management system, and who will be responsible for entering and organizing the data for analysis during data team meetings?
- Are there existing digital subscriptions or instructional resource platforms available through the district that can be utilized for the intervention, or will the school need to purchase new materials within the estimated $500 budget?
- What specific math content standards and instructional priorities has the district curriculum coordinator identified as focus areas for professional development to ensure alignment with district-wide goals?
- How will confidentiality and voluntary participation be maintained if the instructional coach who facilitates the intervention also serves in an evaluative capacity for teacher performance reviews?
- What communication protocols should be established with parents beyond initial letters, and are translation services available for families whose primary language is not English?
- How will student absences during the 4–5 week intervention period be tracked and addressed to ensure that frequently absent students still benefit from improved instruction?
- What format and timeline does the principal prefer for receiving progress updates, and are there specific metrics or evidence of implementation that administration wants to monitor regularly?
- If preliminary data at Week 3 suggests that certain components of the intervention (e.g., differentiation strategies) are not being implemented consistently, what mid-course adjustments are permissible without compromising the integrity of the planned intervention design?
- How will the school ensure that collaborative structures (data team meetings, coaching cycles) continue beyond the initial 4–5 week implementation period to sustain instructional improvements over the full academic year?
- Are there opportunities to engage external partners, such as university faculty or mathematics education consultants, to provide additional expertise or validation of the intervention design and implementation quality?
Guiding Questions
Guiding questions provide the evaluative framework for assessing both the implementation process and the outcomes of the applied improvement project, ensuring systematic data collection that captures how the intervention was delivered. The strategic formulation of guiding questions is a critical component of action research, as the questions establish the boundaries of inquiry and determine the depth and scope of evidence gathered throughout the improvement cycle (Wohlin & Runeson, 2021).
The questions are divided into two categories: process guiding questions, which document the fidelity and quality of intervention implementation, and outcome guiding questions, which measure the effectiveness of the intervention in addressing the identified problem of practice. Together, the questions direct data collection procedures, inform analysis strategies, and establish the evidence base necessary to determine whether the math-specific professional development program paired with structured weekly collaborative data team meetings successfully improved middle school mathematics instruction and student proficiency.
Process Guiding Questions
- How will the math-specific professional development program, paired with structured weekly collaborative data team meetings, prepare teacher participants to implement differentiated instructional strategies and data-driven planning to improve middle school mathematics achievement?
- How will the teacher participants implement the differentiated instructional strategies and data-informed planning practices that they learned during the professional development sessions and collaborative data team meetings in their daily mathematics instruction?
- How will the instructional coaching cycles (classroom observations and feedback conversations) support teachers’ application of newly learned strategies and sustain implementation fidelity throughout the 4–5 week intervention period??
Outcome Guiding Questions
- In what ways are teacher participants implementing the differentiated instructional strategies and data-driven planning practices presented during the professional development and collaborative data team meetings in their mathematics classrooms following the intervention?
- In what ways did the implementation of the math-specific professional development program paired with structured weekly collaborative data team meetings improve teacher confidence, instructional quality, and student mathematics proficiency at the middle school level?
- What parts of the intervention implementation (professional development sessions, collaborative data team meetings, or instructional coaching cycles) were most effective in strengthening teacher capacity and improving student outcomes, and what aspects could be improved for future implementation or sustainability?
Data Collection Plan
To answer the process and outcome guiding questions and evaluate the effectiveness of the applied improvement project, a comprehensive qualitative data collection plan has been developed that aligns with the intervention’s implementation timeline and evidence requirements. The plan incorporates multiple qualitative data sources collected before, during, and after the 4–5 week intervention period to capture both implementation fidelity (process data) and impact on teacher practice and student learning (outcome data).
Consistent with action research methodology, which is inherently qualitative in nature, the study utilizes rich, descriptive data gathered through semi-structured interviews, implementation journaling, coaching observation notes, and collaborative meeting artifacts to tell the comprehensive story of how the intervention was implemented and what outcomes emerged (Lim, 2024). Given the small sample size of eight teacher participants and the relatively brief intervention timeframe, a qualitative approach provides the depth and contextual understanding necessary to evaluate intervention effectiveness and inform future implementation decisions.
Table 2
Data Collection Plan
Guiding Questions | Type of Data | Data Source | When Collected | P or O |
Process Q1: How will the math-specific professional development program paired with structured weekly collaborative data team meetings prepare teacher participants to implement differentiated instructional strategies and data-driven planning? | Pre-intervention interviews (qualitative); PD feedback forms (qualitative); AIP Implementation Journal (qualitative) | 8 math teachers; Applied researcher | Pre-intervention: 1 week before Week 1; Week 1 Days 1 & 3; Ongoing Weeks 1-5 | Process |
Process Q2: How will teacher participants implement the differentiated instructional strategies and data-informed planning practices learned during professional development and data team meetings? | AIP Implementation Journal (qualitative); Coaching observation notes (qualitative); Data team meeting notes and lesson plan artifacts (qualitative) | Applied researcher; Instructional coach; Teachers | Ongoing Weeks 1-5; Weekly Weeks 2-5 | Process |
Process Q3: How will instructional coaching cycles support teachers’ application of newly learned strategies and sustain implementation fidelity? | Coaching observation notes (qualitative); Coaching feedback conversation notes (qualitative); AIP Implementation Journal (qualitative) | Instructional coach; Applied researcher | Weeks 2-5 (two coaching cycles per teacher) | Process |
Outcome Q1: In what ways are teacher participants implementing differentiated instructional strategies and data-driven planning practices following the intervention? | Post-intervention interviews (qualitative); Coaching observation notes (qualitative); Lesson plan artifacts (qualitative) | 8 math teachers; Instructional coach | Week 6 (interviews); Week 5 (final observations); Weeks 4-5 (artifacts) | Outcome |
Outcome Q2: In what ways did the intervention improve teacher confidence, instructional quality, and student mathematics proficiency? | Post-intervention interviews (qualitative); Coaching observation notes comparison (qualitative); AIP Implementation Journal synthesis (qualitative) | 8 math teachers; Instructional coach; Applied researcher | Week 6 | Outcome |
Outcome Q3: What parts of the intervention were most effective, and what could be improved? | Post-intervention interviews (qualitative); Stakeholder feedback surveys (qualitative); AIP Implementation Journal reflections (qualitative) | 8 math teachers; 3 school leaders; Applied researcher | Week 6 | Outcome |
The data collection is to take place in three phases. Pre-intervention (1 week before Week 1): A short baseline interview (15-20 minutes) will be carried out with eight teacher participants to determine the level of current confidence, current practices, and willingness to change. In the intervention (Weeks 1-5), the applied researcher will keep an AIP Implementation Journal where he/she records observations and participant reactions, challenges, and discoveries twice a week. Feedback forms are completed after the Week 1 sessions regarding the professional development. The instructional coach will observe classrooms (15-20 minutes) and hold feedback meetings with each teacher (20-30 minutes) (two full cycles) and record the implementation in the form of narrative notes.
Meeting notes and lesson plan artifacts that are a product of weekly data team meetings are indicators of collaborative data utilization. Post-intervention (Week 6): Detailed interviews (30-45 minutes) will be conducted to understand the implementation experiences and perceived confidence and practice changes, student improvements, and suggestions. Leadership views are obtained through optional stakeholder surveys. All the interviews are audio-recorded, transcribed word-for-word, and given identifiers of the participants in order to preserve confidentiality (Eftekhari, 2024). The applied researcher records journals thematically, and the instructional coach undertakes comparative analysis of early and late observation notes so as to record growth patterns. All data is stored in a safe place on password-protected devices, where it is encrypted in backup.
Qualitative Data Collection Instruments
A rigorous and systematic methodological approach is essential for generating credible evidence and ensuring the validity of findings in applied improvement research. The only methodological approach is qualitative data collection, which is aligned with the action research methodology, where the understanding is based on rich and descriptive data (Lim, 2024). The presence of various qualitative tools will guarantee triangulation and the full provision of answers to all the guiding questions. Semi-structured interviews and the AIP Implementation Journal are the two data sources that are needed in all the implemented improvement projects.
The baseline interviews (15-20 minutes) are conducted pre-intervention to determine the existing confidence levels, practices, and challenges of teachers; at the same time, detailed post-intervention interviews (30-45 minutes) are conducted to determine implementation experiences, perceived changes, and recommendations. Process and outcome guiding questions are based on the principles of social cognitive theory of self-efficacy and observational learning and are designed in the form of open-ended questions included in interview procedures (Zhai et al., 2023). The AIP Implementation Journal is an online journal kept by the applied researcher in which real-time observations, reflections, informal conversations, and implementation developments during Weeks 1-6 are recorded in a semi-structured template with consistent prompts. The data source alignment tables (see Appendix B) indicate the way every data source is systematically addressed to the particular guiding questions.
Interviews
Semi-structured interviews will be carried out in two stages to capture the process and the results of implementation. Pre-intervention baseline interviews (15-20 minutes) that will be held the week before Week 1 will determine the current level of teacher confidence, the current instructional practices, current data use patterns, current differentiation difficulties, and current perception of professional learning needs. The baseline interviews serve to make comparisons on changes reported during the post-intervention interviews (Xu et al., 2025).
Professional development, data team meetings, and coaching cycles, perceived change in confidence and instructional quality, implementation challenges and successes, and observations of student learning improvements, most valuable intervention components, and recommendations for sustainability and refinement are explored in comprehensive post-intervention interviews (30-45 minutes) conducted in Week 6. The applied researcher will carry out all the interviews one-on-one in confidential settings to facilitate confidentiality and free flow of information.
The interviews will be based on standardized procedures (see Appendix A) with pre-tested open-ended questions and will be flexible to delve deeper into the responses. The queries can be based on social cognitive theory, which examines self-efficacy beliefs and observational learning experiences, as well as the environmental supports that can affect behavior change (Zhai et al., 2023). Participation in interviews is based on informed consent, and the audio is recorded, transcribed word-for-word, and given identifiers to the participants. Tables of data source alignment (Appendix B) indicate systematic data correlation of interview questions with guiding questions to cover all objectives of the research.
AIP Implementation Journal
The AIP implementation journal is a required qualitative data source maintained by the applied researcher throughout Weeks 1-6, documenting observations, reflections, informal conversations, challenges, participant responses, and implementation insights in real time. The journal creates a detailed audit trail of implementation activities, captures observations that memory cannot reliably preserve, documents implementation fidelity and adaptations, provides contextual data explaining other findings, and supports researcher reflexivity by examining assumptions and decision-making processes.
Journal entries are recorded electronically using a password-protected document with a semi-structured template organized by week and activity (Danielsson & Berge, 2020). The researcher commits to twice-weekly entries (20-30 minutes each) with additional entries when significant events occur. Each entry follows consistent prompts: What activities occurred? What went as planned or unexpectedly? How did participants respond? What challenges emerged, and how were they addressed? What facilitated smooth implementation? What informal insights emerged? What am I learning about effective implementation? What questions remain? The journal tells the comprehensive “story” of implementation, capturing nuances and complexities that structured instruments miss. At Week 6, the researcher systematically reviews and codes entries thematically to identify patterns related to successes, challenges, facilitating factors, and recommendations, integrating findings with interview data for comprehensive process analysis.
Data Analysis Plan
The data analysis plan provides a methodical process of arranging, analyzing, and interpreting qualitative data that will be gathered during the applied improvement project. The analysis processes are aimed at responding to the process and outcome guiding questions by employing rigorous qualitative approaches such as thematic coding, constant comparative analysis, and triangulation of several sources of data. All the data will be systematized, secured, and kept safely as per ethical research procedures in order to achieve confidentiality and data integrity during analysis.
Table 3
Data Analysis Plan
Type of Data | Analysis Procedures/Plan |
Pre-intervention interviews | Audio tapes will be verbatim transcribed and sent to qualitative data analysis software (NVivo or Atlas.ti). The transcripts will be familiarized through several readings and coded with the help of open coding to identify the first themes associated with baseline confidence, existing practices, and challenges. The codes will be grouped into categories that indicate the level of readiness and preparation required by the teachers. The data will be saved in password-cracking devices that are encrypted. |
Post-intervention interviews | The audio records will be transcribed word to word and loaded to qualitative analysis programs. The transcripts will be coded three times, where the first two coding obstacles will be open coding to identify the emergent themes, the focused coding to code the themes by the guiding questions (process vs. outcome) and finally, the axial coding to uncover the connections between the themes. The comparison will be done by the constant comparative analysis of the responses of the participants and the pre- and post-intervention interviews. Themes will be triangulated in terms of AIP implementation journal, coaching observation notes. The data is going to be password-encrypted and stored on the encrypted computers with the backup in the secure cloud storage. |
AIP Implementation Journal | The journal entries will be put together in one document and fed into the qualitative analysis software. The coding will be done based on chronological and thematic patterns through open coding that will identify the patterns related to implementation successes, challenges, facilitating factors, participant responses, and researcher insights. Themes will be sorted into week and by alignment with process guiding questions through focused coding. Memos will be written at different points in time to bring out interpretive insights. The information will be encrypted and stored in coded machines. |
Coaching observation notes | Teacher and observation cycle (early vs. late) summaries will be made and sorted in terms of narrative observation notes. The notes will be coded based on the evidence of variousiation strategies, formative assessment practices, math-specific pedagogy, and student engagement. Patterns will be determined between early and late observations in the comparative analysis. The results will be triangulated with the interview information regarding implementation experiences. The information will be encrypted and stored in coded machines. |
Coaching feedback conversation notes | Teacher edited conversation notes will be summarized thematically, and analyzed patterned around themes of teacher self-reflection, self-efficacy development, goal-setting, and support needs. Codes will be devoted to metacognition and answers to coaching support. Coaching cycles will have the data compared in order to determine growth trends. The data will be encrypted and use encrypted devices to store data |
Data team meeting notes and artifacts | The artifacts of the meeting notes and lesson plans will be evaluated based on the presence of collaboration in data use, the discovery of the gaps in learning, and the translation of data analysis into differentiated instructional planning. The data analysis of documents will be coded in terms of quality of data discussions, collaborative decision-making and consistency of data findings and instructional responses. The data will be encrypted and stored in encrypted devices using passwords. |
Professional development feedback forms | Thematic coding of responses will be performed with the perceived value, readiness, concerns, and support needs patterns to open-ended responses to compile them. Themes will guide the knowledge of how the professional development equipped teachers to be implemented (Process Question 1). The information will be coded and saved in encrypted devices. |
Stakeholder feedback surveys | The responses to the open-ended surveys will be assembled and analyzed in a thematic manner that would reflect on the opinions of the leadership regarding the quality of the implementation, the changes that were observed, the effectiveness, challenges, and sustainability suggestions. The results will be triangulated with the data on teacher interviews in order to offer an in-depth assessment. Information will be encrypted and stored in encrypted devices using a password. |
Detailed Qualitative Data Analysis Plan
The qualitative data analysis of the applied improvement project will be based on systematic processes that are based on the action research methodology and thematic analysis methodologies. The process will involve an iterative and recursive analysis procedure, alternating between data collection, coding, interpretation, and checking to achieve credibility and trustworthiness of results (Ahmed et al., 2025). All interviews audio-taped will undergo transcription by a professional transcription service and will be checked by the applied researcher. The transcripts will be written in a form that no names will be used so that the confidentiality of the participants is preserved.
Entries at the AIP Implementation Journal, coaching observation notes, documentation of feedback conversations, and data team meeting materials will be arranged chronologically and by type of data source. All qualitative data will be entered into qualitative data analysis software (NVivo or Atlas.ti) to help to systematize the coding, organization, and retrieval (Smit & Scherman, 2021). The researcher will perform deep immersion in the reading of all the data several times before formal coding commences, where he will make initial analytic memos of first impressions, patterns, and questions.
The analytical procedure will now systematize the raw data into meaningful themes, which will answer the guiding questions of the project. The coding analysis will be performed in several coding cycles. Open coding will be used in first-cycle coding because the information will be analyzed line-by-line to determine discrete units of meaning and give them descriptive codes reflecting what is taking place in the data. The data will generate codes inductively instead of being predetermined, which will enable the researcher to be open to unexpected discoveries. In the first stage, 50-100+ codes are usually produced to reflect the diversity of experiences and observations of the participants in their implementation.
The coding of the second cycle will be based on focused coding, where the researcher will analyze the initial codes to detect the patterns, group similar codes into larger categories, and formulate the preliminary themes to respond to the guiding questions (Ahmed et al., 2025). Focused codes will be organized explicitly in relation to process and outcome guiding questions, creating thematic categories such as “How PD prepared teachers,” “Implementation challenges and strategies,” “Coaching support mechanisms,” “Changes in confidence and quality,” and “Most effective components.” During the coding process, constant comparative analysis will be used, and each new chunk of data will be compared to the previously coded ones to refine the codes and find patterns and consistency (Locke et al., 2020). The multi-layered and iterative methodology guarantees rigorous interpretation based on the lived experiences of the participants and analytical transparency and credibility.
In order to increase credibility, the results will be triangulated through the various sources of qualitative data by assessing the presence of themes in the interviews as classified in the coaching observation notes, AIP Implementation Journal entries, and data team artifacts. The inconsistency of data sources will be examined as a potentially valuable finding. Member checking will be achieved through exchanging preliminary findings with 3-4 teacher participants and requesting the teachers to review the findings, determining whether the interpretations align with the experiences of the teachers and remain relevant to the perspectives of the teachers (Urry et al., 2024). The input of the participants will help in refining the interpretations and enhancing the overall accuracy. During the analysis process, the researcher will create analytic memos in which he/she will record the insights of interpretation, questions, relationships between themes, and discoveries (Fearnley, 2022). The memos also act as a thinking ground to go beyond the description side to delve into greater interpretation relative to guiding questions and the social cognitive theory.
To ensure the confidentiality of the participants, all qualitative data will be kept in a safe place. The materials will be stored in encrypted, password-protected data centers containing audio records, transcripts, journal logs, and observation notes stored in secure cloud storage formats. The paper-based documents will be kept in locked file cabinets. No participant names and identifiable information will be stored along with data in a master key file that will be readable by the researcher only (Miller et al., 2023). Information will be stored until the institutional review board determines so, and then the information will be destroyed securely. The rigor, credibility, and trustworthiness of this process are ensured by the systematic analysis process followed in a multi-step approach, as well as being flexible enough to capture the complexity of the experiences of the participants and the results of the intervention.
Limitations, Validity, And Ethical Issues
Limitations of the Project’s Design
Credibility, Dependability, and Transferability
Credibility
Dependability
Transferability
Ethical Issues, Regulatory Issues, and Risks to Participants
References
Ahmed, S. K., Mohammed, R. A., Nashwan, A. J., Ibrahim, R. H., Abdalla, A. Q., Ameen, B. M. M., & Khidhir, R. M. (2025). Using thematic analysis in qualitative research. Journal of Medicine, Surgery, and Public Health, 6(6), e100198. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.glmedi.2025.100198
Danielsson, A. T., & Berge, M. (2020). Using video-diaries in educational research exploring identity: Affordances and constraints. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 19, e101397. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406920973541
Demosthenous, E., Christou, C., & Pantazi, D. P. (2021). Mathematics classroom assessment: A framework for designing assessment tasks and interpreting students’ responses. European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education, 11(3), 1088–1106. https://doi.org/10.3390/ejihpe11030081
Eftekhari, H. (2024). Transcribing in the digital age: Qualitative research practice utilising intelligent speech recognition technology. European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing, 23(5), 553–560. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurjcn/zvae013
Fearnley, C. J. (2022). Mind mapping in qualitative data analysis: Managing interview data in interdisciplinary and multi‐sited research projects. Geo: Geography and Environment, 9(1), e00109. https://doi.org/10.1002/geo2.109
Glover, T. A., Reddy, L. A., & Crouse, K. (2023). Instructional coaching actions that predict teacher classroom practices and student achievement. Journal of School Psychology, 96, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsp.2022.10.006
Guise, V., Chambers, M., Lyng, H. B., Driftland, C. H., Schibevaag, L., Fagerdal, B., Dombestein, H., Ree, E., & Wiig, S. (2024). Identifying, categorising, and mapping actors involved in resilience in healthcare: A qualitative stakeholder analysis. BioMed Central Health Services Research, 24(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-024-10654-4
Islam, K. F., Awal, A., Mazumder, H., Munni, U. R., Majumder, K., Afroz, K., Tabassum, M. N., & Hossain, M. M. (2023). Social cognitive theory-based health promotion in primary care practice: A scoping review. Heliyon, 9(4), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e14889
Ivarsson, A., Ntoumanis, N., & Nygren, J. (2025). Barriers and enablers of a formal coach development program: A multi-perspective process evaluation. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/17408989.2025.2587028
Javed, I., & Akhter, N. (2024). Exploring the opportunities and challenges of additional academic duties on the performance of teachers in schools. Journal of Excellence in Social Sciences, 3(2), 203–220. https://doi.org/10.69565/jess.v3i2.361
Li, H. (2025). Impact of collaborative learning on student engagement in college English programs: Mediating effect of peer support and moderating role of group size. Frontiers in Psychology, 16, e1525192. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1525192
Lim, W. M. (2024). What Is qualitative research? an overview and guidelines. Australasian Marketing Journal (AMJ), 33(2), 199–229. https://doi.org/10.1177/14413582241264619
Lipnevich, A. A., Mattern, K., & Feddock, C. (2025). Formative assessment and feedback in medical education: A practical guide: AMEE Guide No. 189. Medical Teacher, 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1080/0142159x.2025.2569623
Liu, B. (2024). Strategic planning and resource allocation in higher education institutions. The Educational Review, USA, 8(11), 1359–1364. https://doi.org/10.26855/er.2024.11.014
Locke, K., Feldman, M., & Biddle, K. G. (2020). Coding practices and iterativity: Beyond templates for analyzing qualitative data. Organizational Research Methods, 25(2), 262–284. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428120948600
McGuier, E. A., Kolko, D. J., Stadnick, N. A., Frazee, L. B., Wolk, C. B., Yuan, C. T., Burke, C. S., & Aarons, G. A. (2023). Advancing research on teams and team effectiveness in implementation science: an application of the exploration, preparation, implementation, sustainment (EPIS) framework. Implementation Research and Practice, 4(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/26334895231190855
Merwe, D. V. D., Ramsaroop, S., & Fonseca, K. (2024). Teacher educators’ coaching experiences in a mixed-reality simulation intervention. International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education, 14(3), 253–270. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijmce-03-2024-0035
Miller, A. G., Lipscomb, D., & Hornik, C. (2023). An overview of data management in human subjects research. Respiratory Care, 69(2), 256–262. https://doi.org/10.4187/respcare.11578
Motto, M. (2021). Instructional coaching cycles and career and technical educators’ TPACK. Issues and Trends in Learning Technologies, 9(2). https://doi.org/10.2458/itlt.2367
Nobis, M. Jr., & Caparroso, C. L. (2024). Bridging the gap: Examining parental involvement strategies and their impact on homework completion rates in mathematics. Alifmatika Jurnal Pendidikan Dan Pembelajaran Matematika, 6(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.35316/alifmatika.2024.v6i1.1-13
Paulus, D., Vries, G. D., Janssen, M., & Walle, B. V. D. (2023). Reinforcing data bias in crisis information management: The case of the Yemen humanitarian response. International Journal of Information Management, 72, e102663. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2023.102663
Quiroz, F. (2025). Data-literacy professional development: Improving teachers’ understanding for a K-5 mathematics intervention – ProQuest. Proquest.com. https://search.proquest.com/openview/1531433f1d7cde279cfe8e58fd72be89/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y
Schladant, M., Garilli, A., Balzano, G., Natale, R., & Elbaum, B. (2025). Job-embedded peer coaching professional development to support preschool assistive technology use: Teachers’ and peer coaches’ perceptions. Early Childhood Education Journal, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10643-025-02048-w
Smit, B., & Scherman, V. (2021). Computer-assisted qualitative data analysis software for scoping reviews: A case of ATLAS.ti. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 20(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/16094069211019140
Urry, K., Hansen, A. C., & Scholz, B. (2024). From member checking to collaborative reflection: A novel way to use a familiar method for engaging participants in qualitative research. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 21(3), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/14780887.2024.2355972
Weatherton, M., Ko, M. E., Nichols, E. L., Krishnan, S., & Faber, C. (2024). All in: Understanding and motivating stakeholders to create an equitable culture of student success. CBE—Life Sciences Education, 23(4), 10. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.24-02-0065
Wells, L. (2024). Character of coaching: The work of instructional coaches in K-12 character of coaching: The work of instructional coaches in K-12 school districts. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1832&context=cgu_etd
Wohlin, C., & Runeson, P. (2021). Guiding the selection of research methodology in industry–academia collaboration in software engineering. Information and Software Technology, 140(1), e106678. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.infsof.2021.106678
Wullschleger, A., Daly, A. J., Halem, N. V., Merki, K. M., & Rechsteiner, B. (2025). Collaboration on school improvement under different educational accountability systems in two countries. Educational Assessment Evaluation and Accountability, 37, 303–329. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11092-025-09460-1
Xu, Z., Wang, Y., & Qian, Y. (2025). The design and application of in-depth interviews in primary care research. Chinese General Practice Journal, 2(2), e100062. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cgpj.2025.100062
Yang, X., & Du, J. (2024). The effect of teacher self-efficacy, online pedagogical and content knowledge, and emotion regulation on teacher digital burnout: A mediation model. BioMed Central Psychology, 12(1), e51. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-024-01540-z
Zamiri, M., & Esmaeili, A. (2024). Methods and technologies for supporting knowledge sharing within learning communities: A systematic literature review. Administrative Sciences, 14(1), 1–34. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci14010017
Zhai, S., Hash, J., Ward, T. M., Yuwen, W., & Sonney, J. (2023). Analysis, evaluation, and reformulation of social cognitive theory: Toward parent-child shared management in sleep health. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 73, 65–74. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pedn.2023.07.011
Appendix A. Interview Questions
Process Interview Questions
- Describe your experience participating in the two professional development sessions in Week 1. What were the most valuable takeaways for you?
- Tell me about your experience with the weekly collaborative data team meetings. How did the meetings influence your instructional planning?
- Describe your experience with the instructional coaching cycles, including classroom observations and feedback conversations. How did coaching support your implementation of new strategies?
- What challenges or barriers did you encounter when trying to implement the differentiated instructional strategies you learned? How did you address the challenges?
- Describe your confidence in teaching mathematics before the intervention began. How, if at all, has your confidence changed since participating in the intervention?
- What support or resources would you need to sustain the practices beyond the intervention period?
Outcome Interview Questions
- In what ways are you currently using the differentiated instructional strategies presented during the professional development in your daily math instruction?
- How has your use of assessment data to inform instruction changed, if at all, as a result of participating in the data team meetings?
- In what ways, if any, have you noticed changes in your students’ engagement, understanding, or performance in mathematics since you began implementing new instructional strategies?
- Which component of the intervention—professional development sessions, weekly data team meetings, or coaching observations and feedback—was most valuable in helping you improve your math instruction? Why?
- What parts of the intervention implementation were most effective in strengthening your teaching practice? What could be improved?
- Do you plan to continue using the strategies and practices you learned through the intervention? Why or why not?
- What suggestions do you have for improving the intervention if it were to be implemented again or expanded to other teachers in the school or district?
Appendix B. Data Source Alignment Table
Guiding Question | Question Type | Data Source & Specific Questions | Alignment Explanation |
Process Q1: How will the math-specific professional development program paired with structured weekly collaborative data team meetings prepare teacher participants to implement differentiated instructional strategies and data-driven planning to improve middle school mathematics achievement? | Process | Pre-Interview: Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q7 | Pre-interview establishes baseline confidence and practices; Post-interview Q3 explores how PD prepared teachers for implementation; Q4 examines how data meetings influenced planning; Q7 assesses confidence changes; Journal captures real-time observations of teacher readiness and responses; PD forms provide immediate feedback on perceived preparation |
Process Q2: How will the teacher participants implement the differentiated instructional strategies and data-informed planning practices that they learned during the professional development sessions and collaborative data team meetings in their daily mathematics instruction? | Process | Post-Interview: Q6, Q8, Q9 | Post-interview Q6 identifies implementation barriers; Q8 describes actual classroom implementation with specific examples; Q9 examines changes in data use practices; Journal provides ongoing documentation of implementation process; Coaching notes capture authentic classroom evidence; Data team artifacts show translation of collaboration into planning |
Process Q3: How will the instructional coaching cycles (classroom observations and feedback conversations) support teachers’ application of newly learned strategies and sustain implementation fidelity throughout the 4–5 week intervention period? | Process | Post-Interview: Q5, Q14 | Post-interview Q5 directly addresses coaching experience and its role in supporting implementation; Q14 explores ongoing support needs for sustainability; Journal captures coaching dynamics and teacher responses; Observation notes document implementation changes across cycles; Feedback notes reveal teacher self-assessment and goal progression |
Outcome Q1: In what ways are teacher participants implementing the differentiated instructional strategies and data-driven planning practices presented during the professional development and collaborative data team meetings in their mathematics classrooms following the intervention? | Outcome | Post-Interview: Q8, Q9, Q13 | Post-interview Q8 describes specific implementation examples with detailed lesson descriptions; Q9 examines sustained data-driven practices; Q13 assesses intention to continue practices beyond intervention; Observation notes provide objective evidence of implementation; Lesson plans show tangible application of strategies |
Outcome Q2: In what ways did the implementation of the math-specific professional development program paired with structured weekly collaborative data team meetings improve teacher confidence, instructional quality, and student mathematics proficiency at the middle school level? | Outcome | Pre-Interview: Q2 (baseline confidence) | Pre-interview Q2 establishes baseline confidence for comparison; Post-interview Q7 assesses confidence changes with specific examples; Q10 explores perceived student learning improvements; Q12 evaluates overall effectiveness on practice quality; Journal synthesis documents observed teacher growth patterns; Coaching comparison provides evidence of instructional quality evolution |
Outcome Q3: What parts of the intervention implementation (professional development sessions, collaborative data team meetings, or instructional coaching cycles) were most effective in strengthening teacher capacity and improving student outcomes, and what aspects could be improved for future implementation or sustainability? | Outcome | Post-Interview: Q11, Q12, Q15 | Post-interview Q11 identifies most valuable component with rationale; Q12 evaluates what was effective and what needs improvement; Q15 gathers specific refinement and sustainability suggestions; Journal provides researcher perspective on strengths and challenges; Stakeholder surveys add organizational perspective on sustainability and impact |
